You're viewing Docket Item 1 from the case Armour et al v. Monsanto Company et al. View the full docket and case details.

Download this document:




Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 1 of 24

FILED

2013 Jul-30 PM 03:38
U.S. DISTRICT COURT
N.D. OF ALABAMA



IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA

SOUTHERN DIVISION

Clarence Armour, Annie Pearl Bailey, Quincy P. Barclay, Betty Barker, Dorothy Baums, Edna
L. Beal, Barnell Beavers, Edma Mae Berdeaux, Robert E. Blackwell, Warren D. Blair,
Roythron Blake, Lorenza Bloodsoe, Barbara J. Bolding, Geraldrine Bradford, Durrell Donte
Briskey, Shirlene Brooks, Josephine Brown, Linda Brown, Stephanie Brown, Carolyn Brown,
Linda B. Brown, Joseph R. Brush, III, Barbara Bullock, Delderico Bullock, LaToya Bullock,
Quentin Bullock, Thomas Earl, Bullock, Sr., Sherryl Bullock, Willie Pearl Bush, Max L. Butler,
Georgia Calhoun, Vick E. Calhoun, Demetrious Carmichael, Mary Carmichael, Forrest C. Carr,
Tamela L. Carr, Berysce Carter, Tamekia Chapman, David Clapper, Joey Wayne Clapper,
Joyce Clark, Barbara Clark, Exielena Greene, Derriel P. Clayton, George Cobb, Jr., Sherry D.
Copeland, Charlie Cosby, Valerie Cousin, Evelyn Crawford, Annie D. Crowe, Ollie M.
Cunningham, Alexander Curry, Joseph Curry, Pamela Curry, Mary Daviston, Gloria B.
DeRamus, Michael Drake, Darionte Duncan, Yoshika Duncan, Claudia C. Elston, Deborah
Elston, Olisha Le Chelle English, Sharon Faulkner, Steven Ferrell, Tiffany Michael Ferrell,
Tujuaner Renay Fields, James E. George, Marlene George, Charles Goggins, Elbert Goodman,
Daryl Green, Mattie Hardaway, Linda Harden, Ronald Hardin, Ronnie Hardin, Debra Harris,
Lemuel Heard, Barbara Henderson, Robert Henderson, Carolyn Higgins, Deborah Hughes,
Patricia Bush Hughley, Merinda Hutchings, Domanic Hutchinson, Julietta Hutchinson, Omar
Hutchinson, Sylvester Hutchinson, Calvin Ingram, Johnny Ingram, Andrew Jackson, Clarence
Jackson, John Jackson, Latasha Renee Jackson, Lula M. Jenkins, Betty Johnson, Cynthia
Johnson, Katie Johnson, Robert Johnson, William Johnson, Gwendolyn Jones, Mary Jones,
Norma Jones, Reginald D. Jones, William Jones, James Jones, Amanda Jordan, Tabatha
Jordan, Terez Jordan, Jacqueline Keith, Kilup Keith, Phillip Keith, Gelaine Kelley, Linda
Kelley, Jennifer Kendrick, Sonya Kendrick, William E. Kendrick, Fannie L. Kirby, Carshena
Kirksey, Calief D. Lanier, Teresa A. Lanier, Tereshall Renee Lanier, Germika Lushun Lawler,
Anthony Dewayne Lawler, Geraldrine Lawler, Gerard Lynn Lawler, Willie Lawler, Alonzo
Leonard, Alonzo L. Leonard, Ella L. Leonard, Medral Leonard, Javonte Aquinton Mallard,
Sharon Marchman, Sr., Rosemary Martin, Lela McClendon, Alvin Edward McElderly,
Kuneisha K. McFarlane, Mary McKenzie, Kimberly McKinney, Regina Dazelle Pope McNeal,
Sr., Eugenia A. Millender, Doris Jo Mitchell, Willie T. Mitchell, Latoya Mixon, Millicent L.
Monk, Mary Montgomery, Vincent Montgomery, Chantelle Moore, Christy Moore, Edward L.
Moore, Fashionette Moore, Joel Moore, Josephine Johnson Moore, Kimberly Moore, Milton B.
Moore, Paula F. Moore, Eddie Wayne Moore, Jr., Bobby Gene Morris, Letha Morris, Raynetha
Beck Morris, Kakuyna Morris, Cynthia A. Mosley, Joshua R. Mosley, Nancy Mosley, Natheniel
Mosley, Cael A. Motley, Larry Murry, Jessica Nail, Kelvin Nail, Shamika Nail, Daisy Nixon,
Jesse O. Nixon, Joshua Norman, Sheddrick Northard, Antonio Oliver, Aloysius Palmore,
Laquita Patterson, DeJuan E. Perkins, Jessica Phillips, Josephine Pope, Lula Pope, Lawrence
Pottard, Eva M. Pugh, Jariva Pugh, Tanisha C. Pugh, James Quick, Patrica Quick, Truman
Quick, Patricia Reaves, Angela Reed, Shanti Reed, Tamika Reed, Frances J. Roper, Miriam
Rutledge, Arthur Sanders, Brandon Sanders, Eugenia Sanders, George W. Sanders, Roy
Rogers Sanders, Vivian Sanders, Kenneth Satcher, Jerre Lynn Scott, Charles Sims, Brenda
Smith, Carnel Smith, Charles Smith, Christopher G. Smith, Deborah Smith, Elaine Smith,
George E. Smith, James Haywood Smith, Reginald Smith, James Spicer, Ladrester C. Spigner,

1

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 2 of 24

Plaintiffs,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT UNDER RULE 60(d), FED.R.CIV.P.,
TO DECLARE VOID THE JUDGMENT OF SEPTEMBER 9, 2003

Rashaan Jaali Spigner, Wanda Quick Stephens, Creola Stoudemire, Annie Sullivan, Mary L.
Sumlin, Robert Sumlin, Clarence Taylor, Sr., Doris Taylor, Melvin Taylor, James Thomas,
Jamie Thomas, Jeanette Thomas, Sandra Thomas, Andrew Tippins, Gerald Tippins, LaDonna
Tippins, Joe Ann Truss, Tanishia Truss, Debra Turner, Gloria Turner, Henry Turner, Tonesha
Turner, James Tyson, Joe Underwood, Pamela Vincent, Andrew Walker, Hattie Mae Ward,
Costella Ware, Ethlebert Westerfield, Ronnie Westerfield, Anthony White, Linda F. White,
Randy Scott White, Frank Whitson, Myrtis Marie Whitson, Antonio Williams, Brenda
Williams, Carol Onetia Ragland Williams, Chrystal E. Williams, Denese Williams, George
Williams, Loumerrell Willington, Gregory B. Willis, Brenda Wilson, Charles Wilson, Donna
Wilson, Dorian Wilson, Judia Wilson, Steve Wilson, Loretta S. Woodard, Marilyn Woodgett,
Betty Woodgett, Jonah Woodgett, Annie Woodgett, Mary Jo Woodgett, Millard M. Woodrow,
Danny Woods, Gwendolyn Wynn, on behalf of themselves individually and all others
similarly situated,



v.
Monsanto Company, Solutia. Pharmacia Corporation.






COME NOW the Plaintiffs and pray that this Court to declare void and to set aside
the judgment of September 9, 2003, titled “Final Judgment and Order” in Tolbert et al. v.
Monsanto et al., 01-C-1407-S, and Oliver et al. v. Monsanto et al., 02-C-0836-S, because the
Court lacked subject matter and personal jurisdiction at the time it entered the judgment
and order and, as grounds therefor, say as follows:
I.
JURISDICTION

This Court has jurisdiction of this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (federal

question jurisdiction) and Rule 60(d), Fed.R.Civ.P.
II.
PARTIES


1.



2

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 3 of 24

2.


Clarence Armour, Annie Pearl Bailey, Quincy P. Barclay, Betty Barker,
Dorothy Baums, Edna L. Beal, Barnell Beavers, Edma Mae Berdeaux, Robert E. Blackwell,
Warren D. Blair, Roythron Blake, Lorenza Bloodsoe, Barbara J. Bolding, Geraldrine
Bradford, Durrell Donte Briskey, Shirlene Brooks, Josephine Brown, Linda Brown,
Stephanie Brown, Carolyn Brown, Linda B. Brown, Joseph R. Brush, III, Barbara Bullock,
Delderico Bullock, LaToya Bullock, Quentin Bullock, Thomas Earl, Bullock, Sr., Sherryl
Bullock, Willie Pearl Bush, Max L. Butler, Georgia Calhoun, Vick E. Calhoun, Demetrious
Carmichael, Mary Carmichael, Forrest C. Carr, Tamela L. Carr, Berysce Carter, Tamekia
Chapman, David Clapper, Joey Wayne Clapper, Joyce Clark, Barbara Clark, Exielena Greene,
Derriel P. Clayton, George Cobb, Jr., Sherry D. Copeland, Charlie Cosby, Valerie Cousin,
Evelyn Crawford, Annie D. Crowe, Ollie M. Cunningham, Alexander Curry, Joseph Curry,
Pamela Curry, Mary Daviston, Gloria B. DeRamus, Michael Drake, Darionte Duncan, Yoshika
Duncan, Claudia C. Elston, Deborah Elston, Olisha Le Chelle English, Sharon Faulkner,
Steven Ferrell, Tiffany Michael Ferrell, Tujuaner Renay Fields, James E. George, Marlene
George, Charles Goggins, Elbert Goodman, Daryl Green, Mattie Hardaway, Linda Harden,
Ronald Hardin, Ronnie Hardin, Debra Harris, Lemuel Heard, Barbara Henderson, Robert
Henderson, Carolyn Higgins, Deborah Hughes, Patricia Bush Hughley, Merinda Hutchings,
Domanic Hutchinson, Julietta Hutchinson, Omar Hutchinson, Sylvester Hutchinson, Calvin
Ingram, Johnny Ingram, Andrew Jackson, Clarence Jackson, John Jackson, Latasha Renee
Jackson, Lula M. Jenkins, Betty Johnson, Cynthia Johnson, Katie Johnson, Robert Johnson,
William Johnson, Gwendolyn Jones, Mary Jones, Norma Jones, Reginald D. Jones, William
Jones, James Jones, Amanda Jordan, Tabatha Jordan, Terez Jordan, Jacqueline Keith, Kilup
Keith, Phillip Keith, Gelaine Kelley, Linda Kelley, Jennifer Kendrick, Sonya Kendrick, William



3

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 4 of 24

E. Kendrick, Fannie L. Kirby, Carshena Kirksey, Calief D. Lanier, Teresa A. Lanier, Tereshall
Renee Lanier, Germika Lushun Lawler, Anthony Dewayne Lawler, Geraldrine Lawler,
Gerard Lynn Lawler, Willie Lawler, Alonzo Leonard, Alonzo L. Leonard, Ella L. Leonard,
Medral Leonard, Javonte Aquinton Mallard, Sharon Marchman, Sr., Rosemary Martin, Lela
McClendon, Alvin Edward McElderly, Kuneisha K. McFarlane, Mary McKenzie, Kimberly
McKinney, Regina Dazelle Pope McNeal, Sr., Eugenia A. Millender, Doris Jo Mitchell, Willie T.
Mitchell, Latoya Mixon, Millicent L. Monk, Mary Montgomery, Vincent Montgomery,
Chantelle Moore, Christy Moore, Edward L. Moore, Fashionette Moore, Joel Moore,
Josephine Johnson Moore, Kimberly Moore, Milton B. Moore, Paula F. Moore, Eddie Wayne
Moore, Jr., Bobby Gene Morris, Letha Morris, Raynetha Beck Morris, Kakuyna Morris,
Cynthia A. Mosley, Joshua R. Mosley, Nancy Mosley, Natheniel Mosley, Cael A. Motley, Larry
Murry, Jessica Nail, Kelvin Nail, Shamika Nail, Daisy Nixon, Jesse O. Nixon, Joshua Norman,
Sheddrick Northard, Antonio Oliver, Aloysius Palmore, Laquita Patterson, DeJuan E.
Perkins, Jessica Phillips, Josephine Pope, Lula Pope, Lawrence Pottard, Eva M. Pugh, Jariva
Pugh, Tanisha C. Pugh, James Quick, Patrica Quick, Truman Quick, Patricia Reaves, Angela
Reed, Shanti Reed, Tamika Reed, Frances J. Roper, Miriam Rutledge, Arthur Sanders,
Brandon Sanders, Eugenia Sanders, George W. Sanders, Roy Rogers Sanders, Vivian
Sanders, Kenneth Satcher, Jerre Lynn Scott, Charles Sims, Brenda Smith, Carnel Smith,
Charles Smith, Christopher G. Smith, Deborah Smith, Elaine Smith, George E. Smith, James
Haywood Smith, Reginald Smith, James Spicer, Ladrester C. Spigner, Rashaan Jaali Spigner,
Wanda Quick Stephens, Creola Stoudemire, Annie Sullivan, Mary L. Sumlin, Robert Sumlin,
Clarence Taylor, Sr., Doris Taylor, Melvin Taylor, James Thomas, Jamie Thomas, Jeanette
Thomas, Sandra Thomas, Andrew Tippins, Gerald Tippins, LaDonna Tippins, Joe Ann Truss,

4



Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 5 of 24

Tanishia Truss, Debra Turner, Gloria Turner, Henry Turner, Tonesha Turner, James Tyson,
Joe Underwood, Pamela Vincent, Andrew Walker, Hattie Mae Ward, Costella Ware,
Ethlebert Westerfield, Ronnie Westerfield, Anthony White, Linda F. White, Randy Scott
White, Frank Whitson, Myrtis Marie Whitson, Antonio Williams, Brenda Williams, Carol
Onetia Ragland Williams, Chrystal E. Williams, Denese Williams, George Williams,
Loumerrell Willington, Gregory B. Willis, Brenda Wilson, Charles Wilson, Donna Wilson,
Dorian Wilson, Judia Wilson, Steve Wilson, Loretta S. Woodard, Marilyn Woodgett, Betty
Woodgett, Jonah Woodgett, Annie Woodgett, Mary Jo Woodgett, Millard M. Woodrow,
Danny Woods, and Gwendolyn Wynn. The Plaintiffs are 271 of the 7,159 people who were
not before the Court on September 9, 2003 when the Court approved the settlement
agreement, including attorney’s fees, in a final judgment and order but are persons whom
the Court attempted to bind by the judgment and order the 7,159 people who were added
to the case by Exhibits A and B to a “Consolidated, Amended and Restated Complaint in the
Oliver and Tolbert cases filed by the counsel for the Plaintiffs on October 9, 2003, thirty
days after the so-called “Final Judgment and Order” was entered by the Court said persons
had not previously been listed as Plaintiffs in the Oliver and Tolbert cases. The Plaintiffs
appear in their individual capacity and as representatives of the remaining 6,884 persons
listed in Exhibit A and B to the “Consolidated, Amended and Restated Complaint” (Doc #
228) filed October 9, 2003.
Prior to September 1, 1997, a corporation that was then known as Monsanto

Company (former Monsanto) operated an agricultural products business (the Ag
Business), a pharmaceuticals and nutrition business (the Pharmaceuticals Business) and a
chemical products business (the Chemicals Business). Former Monsanto is today known as

3.



5

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 6 of 24

Pharmacia. Pharmacia is now a wholly owned subsidiary of Pfizer Inc., which together with
its subsidiaries operates the Pharmaceuticals Business. Today's Monsanto includes the
operations, assets and liabilities that were previously the Ag Business. Today's Solutia
comprises the operations, assets and liabilities that were previously the Chemicals
Business. The following table sets forth a chronology of events that resulted in the
formation of Monsanto, Pharmacia and Solutia as three separate and distinct corporations,
and it provides a brief background on the relationships among these corporations.
September 1, 1997
as Monsanto Company)
• Pharmacia (then known
entered into a Distribution Agreement (Distribution
Agreement) with Solutia related to the transfer of the
operations, assets and liabilities of the Chemicals
Business from Pharmacia (then known as Monsanto
Company) to Solutia.
• Pursuant
the Distribution Agreement, Solutia
assumed and agreed to indemnify Pharmacia (then
known as Monsanto Company) for certain liabilities
related to the Chemicals Business.

• Pharmacia (then known as Monsanto Company)
entered into an agreement with Pharmacia & Upjohn,
Inc. (PNY) relating a merger (the Merger).

• Monsanto were incorporated in Delaware as a wholly
owned subsidiary of Pharmacia (then known as
Monsanto Company) under the name “Monsanto Ag
Company.”

• Effective date of the Merger.

In connection with the Merger, (1) PNU became a
wholly owned subsidiary of Pharmacia (then known as
Monsanto Company); (2) Pharmacia (then known as
Monsanto Company) changed
from
“Monsanto Company" to Pharmacia Corporation; and
(3) Monsanto changed our name from “Monsanto Ag
Company” to "Monsanto Company.”

December 19, 1999
February 9, 2000
March 31, 2000

its name

to



6

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 7 of 24

September 1, 2000

October 23, 2000
July 1, 2000

August 13, 2002
April 16, 2003
December 17, 2003




• Monsanto entered
into a Separation Agreement
(Separation Agreement) with Pharmacia related to the
transfer of the operations, assets and liabilities of the
Ag Business from Pharmacia to us.
• Pursuant to the Separation Agreement. Monsanto was
required to indemnify Pharmacia for any liabilities
primarily related to the Ag Business or the Chemicals
Business, and
liabilities assumed by Solutia
for
pursuant to the Distribution Agreement, to the extent
that Solutia fails to pay, perform or discharge those
liabilities.

• Monsanto completed an initial public offering in which
Monsanto sold approximately 15 percent of the shares
of our common stock
to the public. Pharmacia
continued to own approximately 85 percent of our
common stock.

the
• Pharmacia, Solutia and Monsanto amended
Distribution Agreement to provide that Solutia will
indemnify us for the same liabilities for which it had
agreed to indemnify Pharmacia and to clarify the
parties' rights and obligations.
• Pharmacia and Monsanto amended the Separation
to clarify our respective rights and
Agreement
obligations relating to our indemnification obligations.

• Pharmacia distributed the shares of our common stock
that it owned to its shareowners via a tax-free stock
dividend (the Monsanto Spinoff).
• As a result of the Monsanto Spinoff, Pharmacia no longer
owns any equity interest in Monsanto.

• Pursuant to a merger transaction, Pharmacia became a
wholly owned subsidiary of Pfizer.

• Solutia and 14 of its U.S. subsidiaries filed a voluntary
petition for reorganization under Chapter 11 of the
U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Prior to and following this
filing, Monsanto assumed the management of certain
tort litigation and environmental obligations in order

7

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 8 of 24

to






February 28, 2008

to protect Pharmacia and itself.
• Solutia completed its reorganization. In connection
with Solutia’s Plan of Reorganization, Solutia,
Pharmacia and Monsanto entered
into several
agreements under which Monsanto continues to
manage and assume financial responsibility for
certain tort litigation and environmental remediation
related to the Chemicals Business. Additionally,
Monsanto received cash and stock from Solutia
(which Monsanto subsequently sold) and various
releases, and Monsanto exercised our right to
designate one member of Solutia’s new board and a
four additional
consent right with respect
members of Solutia’s new board. These agreements
are described in more detail in Monsanto’s Form 8-K,
filed March 24, 2008, and Form 10-Q, filed June 27,
2008. No. 001-16167.
Current
• There is no control relationship among Monsanto,
Pham1acia, or Solutia. However, the indemnification
obligations among the companies and certain service
and supply agreements are ongoing.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

On September 9, 2003, in Tolbert et al., v. Monsanto, 01-C-1407-S and Oliver
et al, v. Monsanto, et al., 02-C-0836-S, this Court approved a settlement of what was
represented to the Court to be 18,000 individual claims for injuries and damages to person
and real property as a result of exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls (“PCB”). These are
chemicals which were used as dielectric and coolant fluids in transformers, capacitors, and
electric motors. These PCBs were toxic and were classified as a persistent organic
pollutant PCBs have been shown to cause cancer in animals and humans. PCBs were
banned by Congress in 1979. Monsanto produced 99% of PCBs used by industry in the
United States at the time they were banned despite the evidence that PCBs caused various

III.


4.



8

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 9 of 24

skin conditions, problems with pregnancies, particularly affecting breast milk, ocular
lesions, irregular menstrual cycles, lowered immune responses, fatigue, headaches, coughs,
alteration of estrogen levels, reproduction problems, liver damage, liver cancer, non-
Hodgkin lymphoma, and disruption of cognitive functions. In short, the toxicity of PCBs can
affect almost the complete range of bodily functions.
Monsanto caused PCBs to be disposed of throughout portions of Anniston,
5.

Alabama and nearby areas, including streams from which fish were taken and eaten by
area residents.

6.
Claims from PCB injuries and damages to Anniston residents and nearby area
residents, former and present, were made on their behalf by various groups of lawyers. A
case known as the “Owens” case, Owens, et al v. Monsanto Company, in the U.S. District
Court, Northern District of Alabama (Eastern), C.A. No.: 1:96-cv-00440-IPJ, was filed and
settled. Two cases in the Circuit Court of Calhoun County, Alabama, Abernathy v. Monsanto
Company, et al., C.A. No.: CV-1996-269, and In the Circuit Court of Etowah County, Alabama,
Abernathy v. Monsanto Company, et al., C.A. No. CV-2001-832, were filed and settled. The
instant case was filed in the U.S. District Court, Northern District of Alabama (Southern),
Tolbert, et al v. Monsanto Company, et al., C. A. No. 2:01-cv-01407-KOB were filed and
settled. There were other related cases, such as Oliver v. Monsanto, in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of Alabama (Southern), 02-C-0836-S, but Owens,
Abernathy, and Tolbert were the principal cases.

Although there were supposedly 3500 individual plaintiffs in Abernathy and
18,000 individual plaintiffs in Tolbert, all of whom were mixed together having all lived in
the same general area, the same amount was paid to settle both cases, $300 million. The

7.



9

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 10 of 24

Abernathy and Tolbert cases were jointly mediated in the federal court with the federal
and state judges both present at the mediation. Only the lawyers were present. The
Plaintiffs were not parties to the case, were not present before the Court and were not
consulted in advance about any settlement on the settlement terms. No effort was ever
made in Abernathy to have a class certified. The federal judge, Judge Clemon, denied class
certification in Tolbert. No reason was given by Judge Clemon as to why he approved a
settlement for the Tolbert case which was so much less per claimant than the settlement in
the Abernathy case or why he approved the same amount of attorney’s fees in Tolbert as
were approved in Abernathy although the results were so much less favorable in Tolbert
($300 million ÷ 18,000 claims) than in Abernathy ($300 million ÷ 3500 claims). The
injuries and damages were not known in either case at the time of the settlements and the
amount of the damages were not presented to either judge.
8.
On September 9, 2003, Judge Clemon entered an order in the Tolbert case

which was styled “Final Judgment And Order”. (Doc. 218). Paragraph 11 of this document
reads as follows: “11. This Final Judgment and Order shall be binding on all parties to
this action and on the entities that have accepted performance or payment
obligations under the written settlement documents. Plaintiffs to be bound
shall be defined as all persons named as plaintiffs in any complaint or
amended complaint filed in these actions to date, together with any person
not so named but subject to the tolling agreement between the parties. The
Court hereby orders plaintiffs to identify all persons subject to such tolling
agreement and to file an amended complaint specifically naming each person
subject to the tolling agreement as an additionally named plaintiff within
thirty (30) days after entry of this Final Judgment and Order. Plaintiffs may
also dismiss certain plaintiffs or specified claims of certain plaintiffs, with the
written agreement of Defendants, or by order of the Court.”





10

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 11 of 24

11.

9.
10.


On October 9, 2003, counsel for plaintiffs in Tolbert filed a document styled
“Consolidated, Amended, And Restated Complaint”. (Doc. 228)

The number of persons listed on Exhibit A to the restated complaint is 1106.
The number of persons listed on Exhibit B to the restated complaint is 6053. These total
7169. The orders entered by the Court on March 29, 2006 (Doc. 548) and November 6,
2010 (Doc 803) state that the Tolbert litigation involved close to 18,000 individual
plaintiffs; the case was not certified as a class action”. (emphasis original). The restated
complaint alleges that Exhibit A to the Ninth Amended Complaint states the names of other
individual plaintiffs, but there is no Exhibit A attached to the Ninth Amended Complaint in
the record of the case. (Doc. 54).
At least 7169 of the individual plaintiffs in the Tolbert and Oliver case were

not before the Court at the time of the “Final Judgment And Order” approving the
settlement was made and entered. There is a clear showing the Court did not even knew
their names, much less what their claims were or the value of them. The above referenced
orders (Doc. # 548 and # 803) show that the Court did not even know how many individual
plaintiffs were before the Court because the language used in the order is that there were
“close to” 18,000 individual plaintiffs. This could reasonably mean any number from
17,500 to 18,500, depending on the judge’s subjective opinion of “close to”, but the point is
the Court did not even know how many individual plaintiffs were before the Court, much
less who they were or what their claims may have been. Nevertheless, Judge Clemon
approved the settlement at $300 million for “18,000” plaintiffs knowing the state case had
settled for $300 million for 3,500 plaintiffs.



11

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 12 of 24

12.

13.

IV


RELIEF REQUESTED


Plaintiffs claim that the Court lacked personal and/or subject matter
jurisdiction of at least 7159 individual plaintiffs and their claims at the time it approved the
settlement of this case and attempted to bind them by the judgment. Since the Court lacked
jurisdiction, the Final Judgment And Order is void.

The Court refused to certify the individual plaintiffs as a class in this case
prior to the entry of the Final Judgment and Order because the Court held that common
questions of law and fact did not predominate. Counsel for some of the plaintiffs had
sought a Rule 23(b)(3), Fed.R.Civ.P., class.
14.
Plaintiffs pray that the Court will set aside the order of September 9, 2003 as

void and will then grant the following relief:
a)
Certify a settlement class under Rule 23(b)(2) and (b)(3);

Appoint the plaintiffs herein as class representatives and counsel as class
b)

lead counsel;
Issue a new hearing date to consider the fairness of the proposed settlement

c)
and the proposed attorney’s fees;
d)
Require counsel who appeared in this case for the individual plaintiffs to

present petitions for attorney’s fees showing entitlement to a fee in a certain amount
supported by those factors approved by the Eleventh Circuit as factors to be considered by
the courts of this circuit in considering the award of attorney’s fees of those lawyers who
do not make such showings, to be required to repay all fees received plus interest since
received;



12

Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 13 of 24

e)

f)



Respectfully submitted,
William Eugene Rutledge


Direct Attorney Edgar C. Gentle, III, to submit to class counsel and to the
Court the names of all persons to whom he as the Administrator of the Tolbert Qualified
Settlement Fund has made payments, the amounts paid to such persons, and the basis on
which the payments and their amount was determined. Further, that the Court direct Mr.
Edward Gentle to also provide the names of all persons to whom payment has been refused
on behalf of the settlement fund and the basis for the refusal.

To grant the Plaintiffs such other, further, and different relief as they may in
the premises be entitled.



/s/William E. Rutledge




PLAINTIFFS DEMAND A STRUCK JURY FOR THE TRIAL OF ALL ISSUES

/s/ William E. Rutledge




OF Counsel:
William E. Rutledge
Rutledge & Yaghmai
Two Chase Corporate Drive
Suite 460
Birmingham, AL 36244
T: 205-985-2411
F: 204-985-2412
[email protected]



JURY DEMAND

TRIABLE BY A JURY IN THIS CAUSE.



William Eugene Rutledge



13











Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 14 of 24

SERVE DEFENDANTS AT:
Monsanto Company
CT Corporation System
2 North Jackson Street, Suite 605
Montgomery, AL 36104
Monsanto Company
c/o CSC Lawyers Incorporating Svc., Inc.
150 South Perry Street
Montgomery, AL 36104
Solutia, Inc.
c/o CT Corporation System
2 North Jackson Street, Suite 605
Montgomery, AL 36104
Pharmacia Corporation
CT Corporation System
2 North Jackson Street, Suite 605
Montgomery, AL 36104



LIST OF PLAINTIFFS AND THEIR ADDRESSES TO FOLLOW:



14

Clarence M Armour
2227 Christine Avenue
Anniston, AL 36207

Betty Barker
940 County Road 269
Wedowee, AL 36278

Barnell Beavers
204 4th Ave
Joliet, IL 60433

Warren D. Blair
1607 Gurnee Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Barbara J. Bolding
1013 Johnson Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Shirlene Brooks
515 West 11th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Linda B. Brown
1709 Johnston Drive
Anniston, AL 36207

Joseph R. Brush, III
1610 Stanley Street
Lot A
Anniston, AL 36201

Quentin Bullock
2936 Rogers Road
Jacksonville, FL 32277

Sherryl Bullock
2936 Rogers Road
Jacksonville, FL 32277


Quincy P. Barclay
507 Livingston Circle
Hobson City, AL 36201

Edna L Beal
3312 Truman Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Robert E Blackwell
71 Garrett Mitchell Drive
Alexandria, AL 36250

Lorenza Bloodsoe
3787 Martin Luther King Jr Dr
F-8
Atlanta, GA 30331

Durrell Donte Briskey
4100 Feather Drive
Douglasville, GA 30135

Linda Brown
146 Yellow Stone Drive
Oxford, AL 36203

Carolyn Brown
625 Glen Addie
Anniston, AL 36201

Delderico Bullock
3501 Townsend Blvd Apt. 302
Jacksonville, FL 32277

Thomas Earl Bullock Sr.
P.O Box 961
Lineville, AL 36266

Max L. Butler
5609 Glade Road
Anniston, AL 36206


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 15 of 24












Annie Pearl Bailey
610 Spring Street
Oxford, AL 36203

Dorothy Baums
929 Isabell Avenue
Anniston, AL 36207

Edma Mae Berdeaux
1705 Pebble Creek Drive
Prattville, AL 36066

Roythron Blake
228 Pine Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Geraldine Bradford
1930 Silverrun Road
Munford, AL 36268

Josephine Brown
1537 Morrisville Road
Anniston, AL 36201

Stephanie Brown
2308 Old Mlitary Road, Apt A
Mobile, AL 36605

LaToya Bullock
1316 Carter Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Barbara Bullock
1316 Carter Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Willie Pearl Bush
606 So. Allen Ave
Anniston, AL 36207













Vick E. Calhoun
P. O. Box 62
Choccolocco, AL 36254

Demetrious Carmichael
26086 Zion Road
RutherGlen, VA 22546

Berysce Carter
1313 Durham Terrace
Mcdonough, GA 30252

Joyce Clark
412 G Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Derriel P. Clayton
5 1/2 Ridge Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Charlie Cosby
P. O. Box 242
Anniston, AL 36202

Annie D Crowe
3030 Gurnee Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Pamela Curry
2117 Gurnee Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Gloria B. DeRamus
2200 Ferron Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Yoshika Duncan
500 Glenn Addie Homes
Apt. C-4
Anniston, AL 36201


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 16 of 24

Georgia Calhoun
P. O. Box 62
Choccolocco, AL 36254

Forrest C Carr
1701 Patch Place
Anniston, AL 36201

Tamekia Chapman
62EA Darden Apt #3A
Anniston, AL 36201

Exielena Greene
1819 Moore Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

George Cobb, Jr.
309 East Glade Road
Anniston, AL 36206

Valerie Cousin
44 Hillside Lane
New Rochelle, NY 10804

Ollie M Cunningham
2946 Columbiana Court
Apt A
Birmingham, AL 35216

Joseph Curry
P.O. Box 4011
Oakland, CA 94614

Michael Drake
111 Elston Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Claudia C. Elston
500 Glendale Avenue,
Apt S3
Anniston, AL 36201


Mary Carmichael
304 McDaniel Street
Hobson, AL 36201

Tamela L Carr
3804 Mary Drive
Oxford, AL 36203

Joey Wayne Clapper
1231 Parker Ln
Oxford, AL 35203

Barbara Clark
2028 Duncan Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Sherry D. Copeland
2013 Hyde Park Lane
Knoxville, TN 37921

Evelyn Crawford
1016 West 13th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Alexander Curry
112 Meadowview Circle
Munford, AL 36268

Mary Daviston
3000 Cresthill Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Darionte Duncan
500 Colenn Addie Homes
Apt. C-4
Anniston, AL 36201

Deborah Elston
40 Corey Circle
Anniston, AL 36201


Olisha Le Chelle English
227 Southmoor Circle
Anniston, AL 36203

Steven Ferrell
626 Spring St.
Oxford, AL 36203

Marlene George
1541 Holly Berry Way
Anniston, AL 36207

Daryl Green
1025 W 14th St
Anniston, AL 36201

Ronald Hardin
27500 Bishop Pk Dr.
Apt W. 507
Willoughley Heights, OH 44092

Lemuel Heard
1826 Abbott Ave.
Anniston, AL 36207

Deborah Hughes
466 Clifton Street
Los Angeles, CA 90031

Domanic Hutchinson
1809 W. 18th St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Slyvester Hutchinson
1832 West 16th. St.
Anniston, AL 36201

John Jackson
9 Robin Rd.
Windsor, CN 06095


Sharon Faulkner
427 Honeysuckle Ridge
Talladega, AL 35160

Tujuaner Renay Fields
121 Stratford Drive
Warner Robbins, GA
31088

Charles Goggins, Jr.
901 W 18th St
Anniston, AL 36201

Mattie Hardaway
100 Richmond Rd.
Apt 439
Euclid, OH 44143

Ronnie Hardin
514C Corkhill Rd. Apt 220
Bedford, Oh 44146

Robert Henderson
2105 Cobb Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Patricia Bush Hughley
1108 Willow Run
Opelika, AL 36881

Julietta Hutchinson
1809 W. 18th St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Calvin Ingram
3804 Ammons St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Latasha Renee Jackson
1111 Boyton Ave
Anniston, AL 36201


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 17 of 24












Tiffany Michelle Ferrell
31 Oakleaf Drive
Eastaboga, AL 36260

James E George
1541 Holly Berry Way
Anniston, AL 36207

Elbert Goodman
709 West 17th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Linda Harden
27500 Bishop Park Dr.
Apt W. 406
Willoughley Heights, Oh 44092

Debra Harris
4604 Saks Rd.
Anniston, AL 36206

Carolyn Higgins
918 W 22nd St
Anniston, AL 36201

Merinda Hutchings
6840 Bridgewood Dr.
Austell, GA 30168

Omar Hutchinson
1832 West 16th. St.
Anniston, AL 36301

Johnny Ingram
1002 Wainwright Ave.
Gadsen, AL 35903

Lula M. Jenkins
6020 E 129th
Grandview, MO 64030


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 18 of 24

Betty Johnson
1205 Christine Ave.
Apt D
Anniston, AL 36207

William Johnson
1508 E. 11th St.
Anniston, AL 36207

Gwendolyn Jones
821 Quail Dr.
Anniston, AL 36201

Norma Jones
3060 Hwy 78 West
Oxford, AL 36203

Andrew Jackson
1732 Stephens Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Tabatha Jordan
523 West St. North
Talladega, AL 35160

Kilup Keith
1304 White Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Gelaine Kelley
1527 Litchfield Ave
Gadsden, AL 35903

Jennifer Kendrick
1315 Packard St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Tereshall Renee Lanier
1906 Brown Avenue #B
Anniston, AL 36201













Cynthia Johnson
1610 Ware St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Robert Johnson
908 W. 16th St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Mary Jones
1307 West 16th St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Reginald D. Jones
410 Elston St.
Anniston, AL 36201

James Jones
1202 Habitat Ln.
Anniston, AL 36201

Terez Jordan
523 West St. North
Talladega, AL 35160

Phillip Keith
4601 Southbury Ct.
Anniston, AL 36201

Sonya Kendrick
1315 Packard ST
Anniston, AL 36201

Fannie L. Kirby
1403 Walnut St.
Gadsden, AL 35901

Calief D. Lanier
1906 Brown Avenue #B
Anniston, AL 36201


David Clapper
1231 Parker Lane
Oxford, AL 36203

Katie Johnson

65 Whispering Pine
Covington, GA 30016

Barbara Henderson
2205 Southland Drive
Anniston, AL 36201

William Jones

1515 McDaniel Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201


Amanda Jordan
523 West St. North
Talladega, AL 35160


Jacqueline Keith
1304 White Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201


Linda Kelley
601 Spring Street
Oxford, AL 36201


William E. Kendrick
1315 Packard St.
Anniston, Al 36201

Carshena Kirksey

3921 Franklin Dr.
Anniston, AL 36207


Teresa A. Lanier
1906 Brown Avenue #B
Anniston, AL 36201


Anthony Dewaye
Lawler
P.O. Box 4124
Anniston, AL 36204

Geraldine Lawler
2605 McKleroy Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Alonzo L. Leonard
2621 Moore Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Javonte Aquinton
Mallard
44 Hickory Dr.
Oxford, AL 36203

Lela McClendon
906 Silver Run Road
Munford, AL 36268

Kimberly McKinney
P.O Box 8103
Anniston, AL 36202

Willie T Mitchell
1023 Ponderosa Trail
Eastaboga, AL 36260

Millicent L. Monk
1825 Thomas Avenue
Anniston, AL 36207

Chantelle Moore
1316 Lytelle Circle
Anniston, AL 36206

Joel Moore
2109 Gurnee Ave
Anniston, AL 36201













Gerard Lynn Lawler
2605 McKleroy Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Willie Lawler, Jr.
445 East 168th Street
South Holland, IL 60473

Ella L Leonard
630 W 14th St
Anniston, AL 36201

Sharon Marchman
212 Jaymar Blvd
Newark, DE 19702

Alvin Edward McElderly
P.O. Box 743
Munford, AL 36268

Regina Dazelle Pope McNeil
205 Spring Chase Circle
Kathleen, GA 31047

Doris Jo Mitchell
4211 Mitchell Road
Anniston, AL 36201

Vincent Montgomery
9253 N. 51st Street
Brown Deer, WI 53223

Christy Moore
5895 Azalea Ridge Drive
Douglasville, GA 30135

Edward L Moore
1316 Lytelle Circle
Anniston, AL 36206


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 19 of 24












Germika Lushun Lawler
917 Woodland Ct
Anniston, AL 36207

Alonzo Leonard
P.O Box 502
Anniston, AL 36202

Medral Leonard
P.O Box 502
Anniston, AL 36202

Rosemary Martin
906 Silver Run Road
Munford, AL 36268

Mary McKenzie
943 Garland Drive
Montgomery, AL 36108

Eugenia A Millender
513 Grammercy Pl
Durham, NC 27704

Latoya Mixon
4131-A Perkerson Drive
Anniston, AL 36201

Mary Montgomery
P.O. Box 211
Eastaboga, AL 36260

Fashionette Moore
2109 Gurnee Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Josephine Johnson Moore
2109 Gurnee Ave
Anniston, AL 36201


Kimberly Moore
1401 Cobb Road
Munford, AL 36268

Eddie Wayne Moore,
Jr. 2109 Gurnee Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Raynetha Beck
Morris
140 Becks Lane
Talladega, AL 35160

Joshua R Mosley
416 Bama Trail
Ohatchee, AL 36271

Cael A. Motley, Jr.
515 Chestnut Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Jessica Nail
1832 West 16th St
Anniston, AL 36201

Joshua Norman
15 Dawvon Terrace
Anniston, AL 36207

Aloysius Palmore
2001 Coleman Road,
Apt B2
Anniston, AL 36207

Jessica Phillips
4009 Turners Mill Rd
Talladega, AL 35160

Lawrence Pottard
2708 Wilmer Ave
Anniston, AL 36201


Milton B. Moore
1401 Cobb Road
Munford, AL 36268

Bobby Gene Morris
306 Anniston Street
Weaver, AL 36277

Sakuyna Morris
1802 West 19th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Nancy Mosley
1500 Valley Place
Anniston, AL 36207

Kelvin Nail
1832 West 16th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Daisy Nixon
139 East Avenue Q-7
Palmdale, CA 93550

Sheddrick Northard
1704 Johnston Ct
Anniston, AL 36207

Laquita Patterson
917 Woodland Ct.
Anniston, AL 36207

Lula Pope
6170 Joyce Lane
Cincinnati, OH 45237

Tanisha C. Pugh
3913 Saint George Terrace
Hiram, GA 30141


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 20 of 24












Paula F. Moore
1316 Lytelle Circle
Anniston, AL 36206

Letha Morris
1925 Rocky Hollow Road, Apt 3
Anniston, AL 36207

Cynthia A Mosley
416 Bama Trail
Ohatchee, AL 36271

Nathaniel Mosley
1500 Valley Place
Anniston, AL 36207

Shamika Nail
1832 West 16th Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Jesse O. Nixon
139 East Avenue Q-7
Palmdale, CA 93550

Antonio Oliver
1809 Moore Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

DeJuan E Perkins
808 Bonnie Drive
Weaver, AL 36277

Josephine Pope
1390 East 25th Street
Cleveland, OH 44112

Jariva Pugh
3913 St. George Terrace
Hiram, GA 30141


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 21 of 24

Eva M Pugh
3913 St. George Tr.
Hiram, GA 30141

Truman Quick
151 Gladden Lane East
Alexandria, AL 36250

Shanti Reed
1700 Dooley Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Eugenia Sanders
1315 Packard St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Arthur Sanders 2705
Pleasant Ridge Dr.
Columbia, SC 29209

Kenneth Satcher
320 Central City Circle
Anniston, AL 36201

Carnel Smith
880 Silver Run Road
Munford, AL 36268

Deborah Smith
3343 Charlemagne Dr.
Decatur, GA 30034

James Haywood Smith
1620 Warrior Rd
Apt #12
Anniston, AL 36207

Ladrester C. Spigner
104 Central City Circle
Anniston, AL 36201













James Quick
P.O. Box 1159
Bynum, AL 36253

Patricia Reaves
3323 Truman Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Tamika Reed
1700 Dooley Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

George W. Sanders
1315 Packard St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Brandon Sanders
2705 Pleasant Ridge Dr.
Columbia, SC 29209

Jerre Lynn Scott
91 Wood Haven Drive
Eastaboga, AL 36260

Charles Smith
154 Parkwood Dr.
Ohatchee, AL 36271

Elaine Smith
880 Silver Run Road
Munford, AL 36268

Reginald Smith
119 Grant St.
Anniston, AL 36207

Rashaan Jaali Spigner
104 Central City Circle
Anniston, AL 36201













Patricia Quick
2313 Nancy Dr.
Oxford, AL 36203

Angela Reed
1700 Dooley Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Frances J. Roper
1945 Buckelew Bridge Rd.
Anniston, AL 36207

Roy Rogers Sanders
1315 Packard St.
Anniston, Al 36201

Vivian Sanders
2705 Pleasant Ridge Dr.
Columbia, SC 29209

Brenda Smith
1619 Charolette Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Christopher G. Smith
880 Silver Run Road
Munford, AL 36268

George E. Smith
26280 Cambridge Dr.
Oakwood Village, OH 44112

James Spicer
83 Lorne Lane
Eastaboga, AL 36260

Wanda Quick Stephens
3412 Truman Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201


Creola Stoudemire
512 West 12 1/2 St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Robert Sumlin
2976 Stone Road
East Point, GA 30344

Melvin Taylor
386 Holland Finley Rd.
Jacksonville, AL
36265

Jamie Thomas
3323 Truman Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

LaDonna Tippins
7610 S. Florissant Street
St. Louis, MO 63121

Tonesha Turner
82 Patton Road
Munford, AL 36260

James Tyson
P.O. Box 2517
Anniston, AL 36201

Hattie Mae Ward
4465 North 27th Street
Milwaukee, WI 53209

Ronnie Westerfield
10714 Eaglewood Ave
Cleveland, OH 44108

Frank Whitson
1324 Kilby Terrace
Anniston, AL 36207













Annie Sullivan
2209 Southland Dr.
Anniston, AL 36201

Doris Taylor
2108 Clydesdale Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

James Thomas
3311 Truman Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Sandra Thomas
232 Sweet Gum Rd.
Columbia, SC 29223

Tanishia Truss
1407 Gulf Stream Cir. Apt. 303
Brandon, FL 33511

Debra Turner
600 W. 11 1/2 St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Joe Underwood
1624 Mulberry Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Costella Ware
707 South Smith Ave
Anniston, AL 36207

Anthony White
304 So. Christine
Anniston, AL 36207

Myrtis Marie Whitson
1324 Kilby Terrace
Anniston, AL 36207


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 22 of 24












Mary L. Sumlin
2976 Stone Road
East Point, GA 30344

Clarence Taylor Sr.
1817 Stephen Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Jeanette Thomas
108 Hidden Pines Road
Columbia, SC 29229

Gerald Tippins
105 Powell Road
Wetumpka, AL 36092

Joe Ann Truss
428 McKinney St
Munford, AL 36268

Henry Turner
600 W. 11 1/2 St.
Anniston, AL 36201

Pamela Vincent
3045 Ellesmere Dr.
Colorado Springs, CO 80922

Ethlebert Westerfield
10714 Eaglewood Ave
Cleveland, OH 44108

Randy Scott White
1604 David Street
Oxford, AL 36203

Antonio Williams
1708 Brown Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201


Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 23 of 24


Brenda Williams
2105 Cobb Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Denese Williams
429 S Christine Av Tinsley Manor
#1-b
Anniston, AL 36207


Brenda Wilson
323 Cedar Lane
Anniston, AL 36206

Judia Wilson
3988 Cottaquilla Rd.
Anniston, AL 36207

Marilyn Woodgett
404 East Sloan Ave.
Talladega, AL 35160

Mary Jo Woodgett
409 S. Allen Ave. Apt. 11-A
Anniston, AL 36207

Danny Woods
458 Shadescrest Drive
Eastaboga, AL 36260

Gloria Turner
P. O. Box 210331
Montgomery, AL 36121
George Williams
314 West 3rd Street
Anniston, AL 36201












Carol Onetia Ragland Williams
2200 Dooley Avenue
Anniston, AL 36201

Loumerrell Willingham
11586 Holmes Rd. #101
Kansas city, Mo 64131

Charles Wilson
1301 Parkwin Ave
Anniston, AL 36201

Steve Wilson
3988 Cottaquilla Rd.
Anniston, AL 36207

Betty Woodgett
404 East Sloan Ave.
Talladega, AL 35160

Annie Woodgett
1108 McDaniel Ave.
Anniston, AL 36201

Gwendolyn Wynn
1170 Wills Farm Rd.
Lincoln, AL 35096

Linda F. White
1302 Winten Place
Anniston, AL 36207

Andrew Tippins
P. O. Box 423
Bynum, AL 36253


Andrew Walker
1624 Dooley
Anniston, AL 36201
Chrystal E. Williams
227 A Street
Anniston, AL 36207

Gregory B. Willis
7603 Holland Drive
Huntsville, AL 35802

Donna Wilson
145-232nd Street
Rosedale, NY 11413

Loretta S Woodard
420 South Marshall st
Anniston, AL 36201

Jonah Woodgett
404 East Sloan Ave.
Talladega, AL 35160

Millard M. Woodrow
3234 GAInes Street
Anniston, AL 36201

Charles Sims

719 Cooper Short Street

Anniston, AL 36201



Dorian Williams



3988 Cottaquilla Rd.


Anniston, AL 36207






































Case 2:13-cv-01408-KOB Document 1 Filed 07/30/13 Page 24 of 24

Larry Murry
12839 Sangamon
Chicago, IL 60643


Clarence Jackson
901 Martin Luther King Dr
Anniston, AL 36201


Miriam Rutledge
3912 Greenbrier Dear Rd.
Anniston, AL 36207
Kuneisha K. McFarland
P. O. Box 3462
Oxford, AL 36203