You're viewing Docket Item 60 from the case Elena Celia Fortaner et al v. The Boeing Company et al. View the full docket and case details.

Download this document:




Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 1 of 13 Page ID #:754

UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL

on

MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION

IN RE: AIR CRASH AT MADRID, SPAIN, ON
AUGUST 20, 2008



MDL No. 2135

TRANSFER ORDER

*

Before the entire Panel : Defendants in this litigation – The Boeing Co., McDonnell Douglas
Corp. (McDonnell Douglas), Esterline Technologies Corp., Leach International, Inc., Honeywell
International Inc., Eaton Corp., and Ametek Inc. – move, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1407, for coordinated
or consolidated pretrial proceedings of the 44 actions listed on Schedule A in the Central District of
California. The defendants’ motion encompasses 41 actions in the Middle District of Florida, which
are consolidated into one action, two actions in the Northern District of Illinois and one action in the
Central District of California.

Plaintiffs in the two Northern District of Illinois actions, the Central District of California action,
and one of the consolidated Middle District of Florida actions support the motion. Plaintiffs in the
remaining Middle District of Florida actions did not respond to the motion.

After considering the argument of counsel, we find that these 44 actions involve common
questions of fact, and that centralization under Section 1407 in the Central District of California will
serve the convenience of the parties and witnesses and promote the just and efficient conduct of this
litigation. All actions concern the cause or causes of the crash of a McDonnell Douglas model MD-82
aircraft operated by Spanair as Flight JK 5022 on August 20, 2008; the flight crashed after takeoff from
Madrid Barajas International Airport in Madrid, Spain. Centralization under Section 1407 will
eliminate duplicative discovery, prevent inconsistent pretrial rulings, and conserve the resources of the
parties, their counsel and the judiciary.

The Central District of California stands out as an appropriate transferee district. Moving
defendants and all responding plaintiffs support centralization in this district, and the presence of some
defendants in the Central District of California provides a connection to the actions. Centralization in
this district also permits the Panel to effect the Section 1407 assignment to an experienced transferee
judge who has not recently received such an assignment and who can steer this litigation on an
expeditious course.

*



Judges Heyburn and Hansen took no part in the decision of this matter.

Feb 12, 2010By Darion Payne on Feb 12, 2010 FILED CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA BY: ___________________ DEPUTY 2/16/2010MADElena Celia Fortaner v. The Boeing Co. 2:10-CV-1149-GAF(RZx) I hereby attest and certify on _________ that the foregoing document is full, true and correct copy of the original on file in my office, and in my legal custody. CLERK U.S. DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA DEPUTY CLERK 2/16/2010MADCase 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 2 of 13 Page ID #:755

- 2 -

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1407, the actions listed on
Schedule A and pending outside the Central District of California are transferred to the Central District
of California and, with the consent of that court, assigned to the Honorable Gary Feess for coordinated
or consolidated pretrial proceedings with the action listed on Schedule A and pending in that district.

PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION

_________________________________________

Robert L. Miller, Jr.
Acting Chairman

John G. Heyburn II, Chairman
David R. Hansen
Frank C. Damrell, Jr.

*

*

Kathryn H. Vratil
W. Royal Furgeson, Jr.
David G. Trager

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 3 of 13 Page ID #:756

IN RE: AIR CRASH AT MADRID, SPAIN, ON
AUGUST 20, 2008

MDL No. 2135

SCHEDULE A

Central District of California

Kim Ivonne Tate Perez, et al. v. The Boeing Co., et al., C.A. No. 2:09-7285

Middle District of Florida

Maria Del Carmen Hernandez, et al. v. McDonnel Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1553
Leandro Ortega Pena v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1641
Angeles Carpintero Ruiz, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1642
Gloria Ester Diepa Martin, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1643
Gloria Ester Diepa Martin, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1644
Higinio Ibanez Fraca, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1645
Eugenio Nunez Pavillard, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1646
Shirley Mani, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1647
Vicenta Guerreo, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1648
Josefa Ortiz Perea, etc v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1649
Carmelo Alvardo Castro, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1650
Juan Diepa Hernanda, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1651
Maria Dolores Florez Rodriguez, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1655
Sonia MAria Castillo Martinez, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1656
Daniel Estevez Ruiz, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1657
Maria Loreto Gonzalez Cabanas, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1658
Zaida Rodriguez Ramirez, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1659
Juan de Dios Font Marin, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1661
Jose Jesus Placeres Perez, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1662
Maximo Diaz Delgado, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1663
Maria Candelaria Perez Mateo, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1664
Tereza Suarez Quebedo, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1665
Rafael Moreno Perez, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1666
Maria Estrella Cigala Marrero, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1667
Maria De La Paz Soto Lloves Concepcion, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al.,
C.A. No. 8:09-1668
Maria Estrella Cigala Marrero, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1669
Maria Estrella Cigala Marrero, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1670
Yolanda Villanueva Martin, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1671
Manfred Mrotzek, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1673
Manfred Mrotzek, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1680
Manfred Mrotzek, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1683

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 4 of 13 Page ID #:757

- A2 -

Middle District of Florida (Continued)

Eugenio Nunez Pavillard, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1684
Angel Francisco Santa Castillo, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1685
Yolanda Villanueva Martin, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1687
Yolanda Villanueva Martin, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1689
Maria Jesus Melian Perez, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1690
Yolanda Villanueva Martin, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1691
Maria Jesus Melian Perez, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1692
Irina Hult, etc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1693
Johan L. Rondonuwu, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1694
Anna Maria Sanchez Diez, et al. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., et al., C.A. No. 8:09-1707

Northern District of Illinois

Elena Celia Fortaner, et al. v. The Boeing Co., et al., C.A. No. 1:09-5808
Antonio Garcia Martin, etc. v. The Boeing Co., et al., C.A. No. 1:09-5810

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 5 of 13 Page ID #:758

UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL

on

MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION

CHAIRMAN:
John G. Heyburn II
United States District Court
Western District of Kentucky

MEMBERS:
Robert L. Miller, Jr.
United States District Court
Northern District of Indiana
Kathryn H. Vratil
United States District Court
District of Kansas
David R. Hansen
United States Court of Appeals
Eighth Circuit

W. Royal Furgeson, Jr.
United States District Court
Northern District of Texas
Frank C. Damrell, Jr.
United States District Court
Eastern District of California
David G. Trager
United States District Court
Eastern District of New York

February 12, 2010

DIRECT REPLY TO:
Jeffery N. Lüthi
Clerk of the Panel
One Columbus Circle, NE
Thurgood Marshall Federal
Judiciary Building
Room G-255, North Lobby
Washington, D.C. 20002
Telephone: [202] 502-2800
Fax: [202] 502-2888
http://www.jpml.uscourts.gov

Honorable Gary Feess
U.S. District Judge
Edward R. Roybal Federal Building
& U.S. Courthouse, Suite 730
255 East Temple Street
Los Angeles, CA 90012-3332

Re: MDL No. 2135 -- IN RE: Air Crash at Madrid, Spain, on August 20, 2008

Dear Judge Feess:

Attached are: (i) a letter directed to the Clerk of your district advising that the above-referenced

litigation has been transferred to you under 28 U.S.C. § 1407 and (ii) a copy of the related transfer order.

As you may know, this office maintains all multidistrict litigation statistics and submits them to the
Administrative Office for inclusion in the Annual Report of the Director. Consequently, once yearly we will
verify the actual number and status of the actions assigned to you, including actions added to the docket either
by transfer of tag-along actions or additional related actions originally filed in your district. You will receive
a copy of our annual inquiry to your Clerk.

You may use our Citrix remote access server to access our database for information regarding assigned
multidistrict litigation. Our database contains transferor and transferee information for your multidistrict
litigation. It identifies counsel who made appearances in the transferor districts, counsel who filed appearances
before the Panel and counsel assigned by you as liaison counsel. It tracks each individual action from the date
of transfer to termination either by dismissal, remand to transferor district, remand to state court, etc. You may
access the server on a Windows based personal computer with DCN access. To use the server, please feel free
to contact our Systems Administrator, Al Ghiorzi, to establish a password and receive instructional information.

Your attention is directed to Rule 7.6 of the Rules of Procedure of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict
Litigation, 199 F.R.D. 425, 436-38 (2001), dealing with termination and remand of actions transferred by the
Panel. Specifically, the rule states, in part, the following:

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 6 of 13 Page ID #:759

- 2 -

(a) Actions terminated in the transferee district court by valid judgment, including but
not limited to summary judgment, judgment of dismissal and judgment upon stipulation, shall
not be remanded by the Panel and shall be dismissed by the transferee district court....

(b) Each action transferred only for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings that
has not been terminated in the transferee district court shall be remanded by the Panel to the
transferor district for trial....

(c) The Panel shall consider remand of each transferred action or any separable claim,
cross-claim, counterclaim or third-party claim at or before the conclusion of coordinated or
consolidated pretrial proceedings on...suggestion of the transferee district court....

We will promptly act upon any written notices from you that remand of actions or separable claims

transferred under Section 1407 is appropriate.

If you appoint liaison counsel, in your pretrial order outlining liaison counsel's responsibilities, please

consider reinforcing Panel Rule 5.2(e), which provides:

If following transfer of any group of multidistrict litigation, the transferee district court
appoints liaison counsel, this Rule [Panel Rule 5.2, Service of Papers Filed Before the Panel]
shall be satisfied by serving each party in each affected action and all liaison counsel. Liaison
counsel designated by the transferee district court shall receive copies of all Panel orders
concerning their particular litigation and shall be responsible for distribution to the parties for
whom he or she serves as liaison counsel.

Thanks for your help. Feel free to contact this office if we may be of assistance to you.

Very truly,



Jeffery N. Lüthi
Clerk of the Panel

By

Darion Payne
Deputy Clerk





Attachments (Separate Documents)

cc:


Clerk, United States District Court
for the Central District of California

JPML Form 23

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 7 of 13 Page ID #:760

UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL

on

MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION

CHAIRMAN:
John G. Heyburn II
United States District Court
Western District of Kentucky

MEMBERS:
Robert L. Miller, Jr.
United States District Court
Northern District of Indiana
Kathryn H. Vratil
United States District Court
District of Kansas
David R. Hansen
United States Court of Appeals
Eighth Circuit

W. Royal Furgeson, Jr.
United States District Court
Northern District of Texas
Frank C. Damrell, Jr.
United States District Court
Eastern District of California
David G. Trager
United States District Court
Eastern District of New York

February 12, 2010

DIRECT REPLY TO:
Jeffery N. Lüthi
Clerk of the Panel
One Columbus Circle, NE
Thurgood Marshall Federal
Judiciary Building
Room G-255, North Lobby
Washington, D.C. 20002
Telephone: [202] 502-2800
Fax: [202] 502-2888
http://www.jpml.uscourts.gov

Terry Nafisi, Clerk
G-8 U.S. Courthouse
312 North Spring Street
Los Angeles, CA 90012

Re: MDL No. 2135 -- IN RE: Air Crash at Madrid, Spain, on August 20, 2008

Dear Ms. Nafisi:

Attached as a separate document is a certified copy of a transfer order that the Judicial Panel on
Multidistrict Litigation issued today in the above-captioned matter. The order is directed to you for filing.
Rule 1.5 of the Rules of Procedure of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, 199 F.R.D. 425, 428 (2001),
states "A transfer or remand pursuant to 28 U.S. C. § 1407 shall be effective when the transfer or remand order
is filed in the office of the clerk of the district court of the transferee district."

Today we are also serving an information copy of the order on the transferor court(s). The Panel's
governing statute, 28 U.S.C. §1407, requires that the transferee clerk "transmit a certified copy of the Panel's
order to transfer to the clerk of the district court from which the action is being transferred [transferor court]."

Rule 1.6(a), pertaining to transfer of files, states "the clerk of the transferor district court shall forward
to the clerk of the transferee district court the complete original file and a certified copy of the docket sheet for
each transferred action." With the advent of electronic filing, many transferee courts have found that it
is not necessary to request the original file. Some transferee courts will send their certified copy of the
Panel order with notification of the newly assigned transferee court case number and inform the
transferor courts that they will copy the docket sheet via PACER. Others may request a certified copy
of the docket sheet and a copy of the complaint (especially if it was removed from state court). You
should be specific as to the files you would like to receive from the transferor courts and if no files will
be necessary, you should make that clear. Therefore, Rule 1.6(a) will be satisfied once a transferor court
has complied with your request.

You may find Chapter 7 of Volume 4 of the Clerks Manual, United States District Courts helpful in

managing the MDL docket.

The Panel Clerk's Office maintains the only statistical accounting of multidistrict litigation traffic in the
federal courts. Therefore, we would appreciate your cooperation in keeping the Panel advised of the progress
of this litigation. We are particularly interested in receiving the docket numbers assigned to each transferred
action by your court; the caption and docket numbers of all actions originally filed in your district; and copies
of orders regarding appointment of liaison counsel, settlements, dismissals, state court remands, and
reassignments to other judges in your district.

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 8 of 13 Page ID #:761

- 2 -

Your attention is also directed to Panel Rule 7.6, regarding termination and remand of transferred actions.
Upon notification from your court of a finding by the transferee judge suggesting to the Panel that Section 1407
remand of a transferred action is appropriate, this office will promptly file a conditional remand order.

Attached to this letter, for your information, is a copy of the Panel Service List. Listed below is the

transferor clerk information:

Very truly,

Jeffery N. Lüthi
Clerk of the Panel

By

Darion Payne
Deputy Clerk

Attachments (Transfer Order is a Separate Document)

cc:

Transferee Judge: Judge Gary Feess
Chief Judge Transferee District: Judge Audrey B. Collins

JPML Form 33

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 9 of 13 Page ID #:762

Printed on 02/12/2010

Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation - Panel Service List

for

MDL 2135 - IN RE: Air Crash at Madrid, Spain, on August 20, 2008

*** Report Key and Title Page ***

Please Note: This report is in alphabetical order by the last name of the attorney. A party may not be

represented by more then one attorney. See Panel rule 5.2(c).

Party Representation Key

* Signifies that an appearance was made on behalf of the party by the representing attorney.
# Specified party was dismissed in some, but not all, of the actions in which it was named as a party.
All counsel and parties no longer active in this litigation have been suppressed.

This Report is Based on the Following Data Filters
Docket: 2135 - Air Crash at Madrid, Spain - 8/20/08
For Open Cases

Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation - Panel Service List

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 10 of 13 Page ID #:763
2135 - IN RE: Air Crash at Madrid, Spain, on August 20, 2008

Page 1

Docket:
Status: Transferred on 02/12/2010
Transferee District:

CAC

Judge: Feess, Gary

Printed on 02/12/2010

ATTORNEY - FIRM

REPRESENTED PARTY(S)

Bartlett, Austin W.
ADLER MURPHY & MCQUILLEN LLP
One North LaSalle Street
Chicago, IL 60602

Collier, Alan H.
MENDES & MOUNT LLP
445 South Figueroa Street
38th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071

Duany-Mendoza, Enid
COLSON HICKS EIDSON
255 Aragon Avenue
2nd Floor
Coral Gables, FL 33134

Gonzalez, Arthur J.
BRENT COON & ASSOCIATES
300 Fannin
Suite 200
Houston, TX 77002

=>Phone: (312) 345-0700 Fax: (312) 345-9860 Email: [email protected]

Honeywell International, Inc.*

=>Phone: (213) 955-7700 Fax: (213) 955-7725 Email: [email protected]

Eaton Corp.*

=>Phone: (305) 476-7400 Fax: (305) 476-7444 Email: [email protected]

Bautista (Per./Rep./Est.-Ronald Gomez Silva & Yanina Nayade Celis Dibowsky), Enrique Celis*;
Caballero Tacoronte (Per./Rep./Est-David), Marcos Alejandro*; Dominguez Perdomo
(Per./Rep./Est.-Isabel Minerva Domingues Perez & Christian Martin Dominguez), Jose*; Fernandez
Rocafull (Per./Rep./Est.-Jose Fernandez Vazquez), Jorge*; Fortaner (Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del
Carmen Fortaner Nau), Elena Cella*; Garcia Martin (Per./Rep./Ests.-Laudencio, Elena & Carlos),
Antonio*; Gil Perez (Per./Rep./Est.-Marcos J Hernandez Gil), Candelaria*; Ojeda Perez
(Per./Rep./Est.-Claudio Manueal), Maria Del Carmen*; Puye (Per./Rep./Est.-Mustapha Paganna
Puye Ceesay & Sira Puye Fortaner), Alasan*; Rivero Perez (Per./Rep./Est.-Alberto Rivero Suarez),
Victor*; Vallejo Junco (Behalf/Est.-Maria Del Carmen), Luis*; Vega Martel (Per./Rep./Est.-Yaiza
Medina), Aquilina*

=>Phone: (713) 225-1682 Fax: (713) 225-1785 Email: [email protected]

Afonso Gonzalez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Pedro Pablo Afonso Marrero, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel
Afonso Dosa), Juan*; Afonso Marrero (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Pedro Afonso, Jorge Afonso Sosa &
Miguel Afonso Sosa), Jose Andres*; Afonso Marrero (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Pedro Afonso, Jorge
Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso Sosa), Juan Salvador*; Afonso Marrero (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Pedro
Pablo Afonso, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso Sosa), AnaCorina*; Barrio Santos
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Teresa Morales & Daniel Payera), Ricardo*; Betancor Sanchez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sanchez Ortiz & Veronica Isabel Bentacor), Leticia Maria*;
Cabrera Herrera (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Siomara Hernandez Cabrera, Abenaura Hernandez Cabrera,
TanausuGonzalez Hernandez), Maria Asencion*; Camacho Rodriguez (Next Friend-Gregoria
Mendola & BRA/Per./Rep./Est.-Alfredo Alonso Acosta Sierra),Juana*; Cruz Quintella
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Isaax Dominguez De La Cruz & Baby Dominguez), Maria Dle RosarioDe La*;
Dominguez Vadillo (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Isaax Dominguez De La Cruz & Baby Dominguez),
Cecilio*; Flores Garcia (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Ana Gema Flores), Jaime*; Gallego Campos
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Cristina Gallego Ortega & Ana Isabel Gallego Ortega), Pedro Manuel*; Garcia
Orcajo (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Ana Gema Flores), Claudia*; Gonzalez Cabanas, Maria Loreto*; Guedes
Perez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Lucrecua Hernandez Guedes, Elena Garcia Hernandez & Carlos
GarciaHernandez), Rosa Maria*; Henriquez Espinosa (Ind./Behalf-Agustin July
Pelegrina/Per./Rep./Est.-Agustin Juli Henriquez & Manuel Juli Henriquez), Margarita*; Hernandez
Deniz (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sosa Hernandez, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso
Sosa), Maria Dolores*; Hernandez Guedes (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Lucrecia, Elena Garcia Hernandez &
carlos Garcia Hernandez), Fernando*; Hernandez Guedes (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Lucrecia, Elena
Garcia Hernandez, Carlos Garcia Hernandez), Antonio*; Hernandez Guedes
(Ind./Per.Rep./Est.-Lucrecia, Elena Garcua Hernandez, Carlos Garcia Hernandez), Rosa Paz*;
Herrarez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Ana Gema Flores), Juan Jose*; Juli Pelegrina (Ind./Behaf-Agustin July
Pelegrina/Per./Rep./Est.-Agustin Juli Henriquez & Manuel Juli Henruquez), Miguel Sebastian*;
Marrero Gonzalez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Pedro Pablo Afonso Marrero, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel
AfonsoSosa), Josefa*; Martin Gonzalez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Manuel Mateo Martin Perez & CDP),
Manuel C.*; Martin Perez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Manuel Mateo & CDP), Cristo Alexander*; Martin
Perez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Manuel Mateo Martin & CDP), Victoria Eugenia*; Martin Perez
(Ind./Per./Rep.Est.-Manuel Mateo & CDP), Miguel Angel*; Miguel Morales

Note: Please refer to the report title page for complete report scope and key.

(Panel Attorney Service List for MDL 2,135 Continued)

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 11 of 13 Page ID #:764

Page 2

ATTORNEY - FIRM

REPRESENTED PARTY(S)

(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Teresa Morales Santos & Daniel Payera Morales), Sarai San*; Morales
Santos (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Teresa Morales Santos & Daniel Payera Morales), Marta*; Ortega
Sanchez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Ortega, Cristina Gallego Ortega & Ana Isabel
Gallego Ortega), Purificacion*; Ortega Sanchez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Ortega,
Cristina Gallego Ortega & Ana Isabel Gallego Ortega), Aurelio*; Ortega Sanchez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Ortega, Cristina Gallego Ortega & Ana Isabel Gallego
Ortega), Jose Enrique*; Ortega Sanchez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Ortega, Cristina
Gallego Ortega & Ana Isabel GHallego Ortega), Soraya*; Pablo Flores (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Ana
Gema Flores), Jose*; Pablo Flores, Jose*; Palomino Riveros, Ligia*; Perez Perez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Manuel Mateo Martin & CDP), Encarnacion*; Piretti Leon
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Eugenia Nunez Piretti & JNP), Maria De Los Angeles*; Ramirez Barbosa
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Jose Ramirez Rodriguez & Maria Del Carmen Elsa Barbosa Ramirez), Monica*;
Ramirez Barbosa (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Jose Ramirez Rodriguez & Maria Del Carmen Elsa Barbosa
Ramirez), Marta*; Ramirez Barbosa (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Jose Ramirez Rodriguez & Maria Del
Carmen Elsa Barbosa Ramirez), Maria Del Carmen*; Ramirez Barbosa (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Jose
Ramirez Rodriguez & Maria Del Carmen Elsa Barbosa Ramirez), Elsa Maria*; Rodriguez Ramirez
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Honorio Hanel Rodriguez Davila), Roberto Angel*; Rodriguez Ramirez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Lourdes Ramirez Gonzalez), Roberto Angel*; Rodriguez Ramirez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Lourdes Ramirez Gonzalez), Zaida*; Sanchez Diez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Betsabe Ibanez Sanchez), Ana Maria*; Santos Molina (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria
Teresa Morales Santos & Daniel Payera Morales), Vidal*; Santos Noguerales
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Teresa Morales Santos & Daniel Payera Morales), Teresa*; Sosa
Hernandez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sosa Hernandez, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel
Afonso Sosa), Rita Maria*; Sosa Hernandez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sosa
Hernandez, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso Sosa), Federico Bonifacio*; Sosa Hernandez
(Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sosa Hernandez, Jorge Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso Sosa),
Santiago Jose*; Sosa Rodrigiez (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Del Carmen Sosa Hernandez, Jorge
Afonso Sosa & Miguel Afonso Sosa), Santiago*; Valles Zurita (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Francisco Javier
Valles Marcos), Lidia*; Vera Torres (Ind./Next Friend-JJVMM/Per./Rep./Est.-Monica Martin
Machin), Juan Miguel*; Vidal Rodriguez, Rafael*; Zurita Hinojal (Ind./Per./Rep./Est.-Francisco
Javier Valles Marcos), Senorina*

=>Phone: (310) 552-3800 Fax: (310) 552-9434 Email: [email protected]

Caballero Tacorante (Ind./Rep./Est.-David), Marcos*; Cabrera Herrera (Ind./Rep./Est.-Siomara
Hernandez, Tanausu Gonzalez & Abenauara Hernandez Cabrera),Maria Ascension*; Garcia Lopez
(Ind,/Rep./Est.-Pilar Lopez Duque & Antonia Garcia Sanchez), Raul*; Garcia Lopez
(Ind./Rep./Est.-Pilar Lopez Duque & Antonio Garcia Sanchez), Ivan*; Marcial Verona
(Ind./Rep./Est.-Angel Jose Mendoza Marcial), Francisca Laura*; Morillo Trujillo
(Ind./Rep./Est.-Patricia Morillo Perez), Raphael Sebastian*; Ojeda Perez (Ind./Rep./Est.-Claudio),
Elsa*; Ojeda Perez (Ind./Rep./Est.-Claudio), Rosario Berta*; Perez Hernandez
(Ind./Rep./Est.-Patricia Morillo Perez), Maria Jesus*; Saavedra Vizcaino
(Ind./Rep./Est.-Rep./Est.-Maria Reitz Saavedra), Cira*; Tate Perez, Kim Tvonne*

=>Phone: (305) 358-2800 Fax: (305) 358-2382 Email: [email protected]

Alvarado Castro (Per./Rep./Est.-Robert Alvardo Coruna), Carmelo*; Carmen Hernandez
(Per./Rep./Est.-Ruben Santan Mateo), Maria Del*; Carpintero Ruiz, Angeles*; Castillo Martinez
(Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Sonia Rodriguez Del Castillo), Sonia Maria*; Cigala Marrero
(Per./Rep./Est.-Jorge Naranjo), Maria Estrella*; Cigala Marrero (Per./Rep./Est.-Raquel Naranjo
Gomez), Maria Estrella*; Coruna Diaz (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Robert Alvarado Coruna), Avelina*;
Delgado (Per./Rep./Est.-Lidia Delgado Estevez), Maximo Diaz*; Diaz Diaz
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Clara Diaz Gonzalez), Jose Luis*; Diepa Hernanda (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Monica
Diepa Leon), Juan*; Diepa Martin (Per./Rep./Est.-Oscar Gabriel Alvardo Diepa), Gloria Ester*;
Diepa Martin (Per./Rep./Est.-Roberto Alexander Alvarado Diepa), Gloria Ester*; Estevez Ruiz
(Per./Rep./Est.-Susana Marin Romas), Daniel*; Florez Rodriguez (Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Lourdes
Romero Florez), Maria Dolores*; Font Marin (Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Jesus Font Rodriguez), Juan de
Dios*; Gonzalez Cabanas (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Clara Diaz Gonzalez), Maria Loreto*; Guerrero
(Per./Rep./Est.-Gabriel Guerreo), Vicente*; Hult (Per./Rep./Est.-Ann Marie Helene), Irina*; Ibanez
Fraca (Per./Rep./Est.-Betsabe Ibanez Sanchez), Higinio*; Mainsiouw (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Nguni
Toka Rondonuwu), Syull*; Mani (Per./Rep./Est.-Gabria Guerrero), Vicente*; Mani

Lack, Walter J.
ENGSTROM LIPSCOMB & LACK
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.
12th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Martinez-Cid, Ricardo M.
PODHURST ORSECK PA
25 West Flagler Street
Suite 800
Miami, FL 33130

Note: Please refer to the report title page for complete report scope and key.

(Panel Attorney Service List for MDL 2,135 Continued)

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 12 of 13 Page ID #:765

Page 3

ATTORNEY - FIRM

REPRESENTED PARTY(S)

(Per./Rep./Est.-Mukesh Bacho), Shirley*; Melian Perez (Per./Rep./Est.-Alicia Dominguez Melian),
Maria Jesus*; Melian Perez (Per./Rep./Est.-Araceli Yolanda Dominguez Melian), Maria Jesus*;
Mrotzek (Per./Rep./Est.-Gerd), Manfred*; Mrotzek (Per./Rep./Est.-Lucas), Manfred*; Mrotzek
(Per./Rep./Est.-Niklas), Manfred*; Nunez Pavillard (Per./Rep./Est.-Jorge Nunez Piretti), Eugenio*;
Ortega Pena, Leandro*; Ortiz Perea (Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Cristian Domiguez Ortiz), Josefa*;
Pavillard (Per./Rep./Est.-Maria Eugenia Nunez Piretti), Eugenio Nunez*; Perez Mateo
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Ruben Daniel Sanchez Perez), Maria Candelaria*; Perez, Rafael Moreno*;
Placeres Perez (Per./Rep./Est.-Ines Placeres), Jose Jesus*; Rivera (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Monica Diepa
Leon), Francisca Leon*; Rodriguez Ramirez (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Honorio Hanel Rodriguez Davila),
Roberto Angel*; Rodriguez Ramirez (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Honorio Hanel Rodriguez Davila), Zaida*;
Rondonuwu (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Nguni Toka), Johan L.*; Sanchez Hernandez
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Ruben Daniel Sanchez Perez), Juan Andres*; Santa Castillo
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Alejandro Aillanueva Santans), Angel Francisco*; Santa Castillo
(Per./Rep./Est.-Carmen Isabel), Angel Francisco*; Santana Castillo (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Keila
Villanueva Santana), Angel Francisco*; Santana Castillo (Co.-Per./Rep./Est.-Dara Villanueva
Santana), Angel Francisco*; Soto Lloves (Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Jorge Naranjo Gomez), Concepcion
Maria De La Paz*; Soto Lloves (Per./Rep./Est.-Cecilia Gomez Soto), Concepcion Maria De La Paz
Soto*; Soto Lloves (Per./Rep./Est.-Raquel Naranjo Gomez), Concepcion Maria De La Paz*; Suarez
Quebedo (Per./Rep./Est.-Jose Vicente Robaina Suarez), Tereza*; Villanueva Martin
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Alejandro Villanueva Santans), Yolanda*; Villanueva Martin
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Dara Villanueva Santana), Yolanda*; Villanueva Martin
(Co-Per./Rep./Est.-Keila Villanueva Santana), Yolanda*; Villanueva Martin
(Per./Rep./Est.-Alejandro), Yolanda*

=>Phone: (213) 955-7700 Fax: (213) 955-7725 Email: [email protected]

Ametek, Inc.*

=>Phone: (312) 602-5000 Fax: (312) 602-5050 Email: [email protected]

Boeing Co. (The)*; McDonnell Douglas Corp.*

=>Phone: (215) 751-2000 Fax: (215) 751-2205 Email: [email protected]

Esterline Technologies Corp.*; Leach International Corp.*

McNulty, Suzanne N.
MENDES MOUNT LLP
445 South Figueroa Street
38th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071

Morof, Jeffrey W.
BRYAN CAVE LLP
161 North Clark Street
Suite 4300
Chicago, IL 60601

Shupe, J. Denny
SCHNADER HARRISON SEGAL & LEWIS LLP
1600 Market Street
Suite 3600
Philadelphia, PA 19103

Note: Please refer to the report title page for complete report scope and key.

Case 2:10-cv-01149-GAF-RZ Document 60 Filed 02/16/10 Page 13 of 13 Page ID #:766

IN RE: AIR CRASH AT MADRID, SPAIN, ON
AUGUST 20, 2008

MDL No. 2135

INVOLVED CLERKS LIST

Michael W. Dobbins, Clerk
Everett McKinley Dirksen U.S. Courthouse
219 South Dearborn Street
Chicago, IL 60604
Docketing ILND/ILND/07/USCOURTS

Sheryl L. Loesch, Clerk
218 Sam M. Gibbons U.S. Courthouse
801 North Florida Avenue
Tampa, FL 33602-3800
Flmd-MDL Litigition/FLMD/11/USCOURTS