Case Details

CourtCourt of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
Docket number10-1063
Date case filed03/16/2010
Date case closed06/21/2011
Date of latest filing
Assigned to
Case cause
Nature of suit
Jury demand
Demand
Jurisdiction

Case Parties

None listed

Case Docket

Docket
Item
Date FiledDocument
Available
Short
Description
Long Description
0120663840703/16/2010 NOTICE OF APPEAL filed [1237261] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service of a decision by United States Tax Court [Service Date: 03/16/2010] Disclosure Statement: Not Applicable to this Party; Certificate of Parties: Not Applicable to this Filing [10-1063]
0120663841303/30/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1237262] directing party to file initial submissions: APPELLANT docketing statement due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT certificate as to parties, etc. due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT statement of issues due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT underlying decision due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT deferred appendix statement due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT notice of appearance due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT procedural motions due 04/29/2010. APPELLANT dispositive motions due 05/14/2010; directing party to file initial submissions: APPELLEE entry of appearance due 04/29/2010. APPELLEE procedural motions due 04/29/2010. APPELLEE dispositive motions due 05/14/2010 [10-1063]
0120663841803/30/2010 LETTER SENT [1237263] regarding attorney membership to Robert J. Onda for Dorothy Jean Simmons. Application for Admission due 04/29/2010. [10-1063]
0120664120303/31/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1237504] by Patrick J. Urda on behalf of Appellant Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120670881304/21/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1240898] by Robert J. Onda and co-counsel Timothy S. Rankin on behalf of Appellee Dorothy Jean Simmons. [10-1063] (Onda, Robert)
0120674582504/30/2010 UNOPPOSED NOTICE filed [1242780] by National Trust for Historic Preservation, The L'Enfant Trust, and Foundation for the Preservation of Historic Georgetown of intention to participate as amicus curiae. [Disclosure Listing: Attached] [Service Date: 04/30/2010 ] [10-1063] (Eisenstein, Matthew)
0120675809105/03/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1242823] by Matthew A. Eisenstein on behalf of Amici Curiae for Appellee Foundation for the Preservation of Historic Georgetown, National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States and The L'Enfant Trust. [10-1063] (Eisenstein, Matthew)
0120675814105/03/2010 DOCKETING STATEMENT FILED [1242856] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ] [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675814505/03/2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE [1242864] to statement [1242856-2] filed by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675816205/03/2010 CERTIFICATE AS TO PARTIES, RULINGS AND RELATED CASES FILED [1242872] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ] [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675816805/03/2010 STATEMENT OF INTENT REGARDING APPENDIX DEFERRAL FILED [1242874] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ] Intent: AppxDeferred [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675817105/03/2010 STATEMENT OF ISSUES FILED [1242875] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ] [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675817405/03/2010 UNDERLYING DECISION IN CASE submitted [1242877] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ] [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120675818005/03/2010 TRANSCRIPT STATUS REPORT [1242890] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 05/03/2010 ]. Status of Transcripts: transcripts needed for the appeal have been ordered, but not all transcripts have been received. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120707978307/20/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1256094] setting briefing schedule: APPELLANT Brief due 09/01/2010. APPELLEE Brief due on 10/01/2010. AMICUS for APPELLEE Brief due 10/18/2010. APPELLANT Reply Brief due 11/01/2010. Deferred Appendix due 11/08/2010. Final Briefs due 11/22/2010. [10-1063]
0120717759208/23/2010 MOTION filed [1262029] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service to extend time to file brief to 10/01/2010. [Service Date: 08/23/2010] Pages: 1-10. [10-1063]--[Edited 08/24/2010 by KRM] (Urda, Patrick)
0120719306108/31/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1263358] granting appellant's motion to extend time [1262029-2]; Revising briefing schedule as follows: [1256094-2] APPELLANT Brief due 10/01/2010. APPELLEE Brief due on 11/01/2010. AMICUS for APPELLEE Brief due 11/16/2010. APPELLANT Reply Brief due 11/30/2010. Deferred Appendix due 12/07/2010. Final Briefs due 12/21/2010. [10-1063]
0120720426210/01/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1269453] by Patrick J. Urda and co-counsel Kenneth L. Greene on behalf of Appellant Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service. [10-1063] (Greene, Kenneth)
0120720427010/01/2010 APPELLANT BRIEF [1269456] filed by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 10/01/2010 ] Length of Brief: 12,010. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120721360911/01/2010 APPELLEE BRIEF [1274718] filed by Dorothy Jean Simmons [Service Date: 11/01/2010 ] Length of Brief: 13,519. [10-1063] (Onda, Robert)
0120721858511/16/2010 AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1277702] filed by Foundation for the Preservation of Historic Georgetown, National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States and The L'Enfant Trust [Service Date: 11/16/2010 ] Length of Brief: 6952 Words. [10-1063] (Eisenstein, Matthew)
0120722011811/19/2010 MOTION filed [1278596] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service to extend time to file brief to 12/21/2010. (Response to Motion served by mail due on 12/02/2010) [Service Date: 11/19/2010 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120722137511/23/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1279384] scheduling oral argument before Judges GINSBURG, GARLAND, SILBERMAN 02/04/2011 AM [10-1063]
0120722184811/24/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1279676] granting appellant's motion to extend time to file briefs [1278596-2] only to the extent that the following revised briefing schedule will now apply in this case: APPELLANT Reply Brief due 12/07/2010. Deferred Appendix due 12/14/2010. Final Briefs due 12/28/2010. [10-1063]
0120722549112/07/2010 APPELLANT REPLY BRIEF [1281785] filed by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 12/07/2010 ] Length of Brief: 6,912 words. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120722825912/16/2010 MOTION filed [1283507] by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service Appellant's Unopposed Motion for Leave to file Corrected Appendix. [Service Date: 12/16/2010 ] Pages: 1-10. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120722831012/16/2010 MODIFIED EVENT FROM FILED TO LODGED--CORRECTED APPENDIX [1283537] filed [Volumes: 3] [Service Date: 12/16/2010 ] [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120722984612/22/2010 APPELLANT FINAL BRIEF [1284516] filed by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 12/22/2010 ] Length of Brief: 12,048. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120723002612/23/2010 AMICUS FOR APPELLEE FINAL BRIEF [1284614] filed by Foundation for the Preservation of Historic Georgetown, National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States and The L'Enfant Trust [Service Date: 12/23/2010 ] Length of Brief: 6952 Words. [10-1063] (Eisenstein, Matthew)
0120723103412/28/2010 APPELLEE FINAL BRIEF [1285172] filed by Dorothy Jean Simmons [Service Date: 12/28/2010 ] Length of Brief: 13,777. [10-1063] (Onda, Robert)
0120723109112/28/2010 APPELLANT FINAL REPLY BRIEF [1285202] filed by Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service [Service Date: 12/28/2010 ] Length of Brief: 6,856 words. [10-1063] (Urda, Patrick)
0120723145412/29/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1285437] granting appellant's unopposed motion for leave to file a corrected appendix (Vol 1-3) [1283507-2]; The Clerk is directed to file the lodged appendix [1283537-2] [10-1063]
0120723701301/18/2011 PER CURIAM ORDER filed [1288460] allocating oral argument time as follows: Appellant -- 10 Minutes, Appellee -- 10 Minutes. One counsel per side to argue; directing party to file Form 72 notice of arguing attorney - due 02/01/2011 [10-1063]
0120724253002/04/2011 ORAL ARGUMENT HELD before Judges Ginsburg, Garland and Silberman. [10-1063]
0120728170506/21/2011 PER CURIAM JUDGMENT filed [1314256] that the judgment of the Tax Court appealed from in this case is hereby affirmed for the reasons in the accompanying opinion . Before Judges: Ginsburg, Garland and Silberman. [10-1063]
0120728171506/21/2011 OPINION filed [1314257] (Pages: 12) for the Court by Judge Ginsburg [10-1063]
0120728172006/21/2011 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1314263] withholding issuance of the mandate. [10-1063]