You're viewing Docket Item 56.1 from the case HATIM et al v. BUSH et al. View the full docket and case details.

Download this document:




Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 1 of 25

1

Chart indicating (1) whether petitioners had materials seized in connection with NCIS investigation; and, if so, (2) whether

respondents have a good faith basis to believe that petitioners had privileged communications with counsel prior to June 18, 2006

EXHIBIT 1









Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Hicks v. Bush, 05-CV-299 (CKK)
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

David Hicks
Omar Rajab Amin
Nasser Nijer Naser Al Mutairi
Khalid Abdullah Mishal Al
Mutairi
Abdulaziz Sayer Owain Al
Shammari
Abdullah Saleh Ali Al Ajmi
Abdullah Kamal Abdullah Kamal
Al Kandari

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK) Mohammed Funaitel Al Dihani
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Fawzi Khalid Abdullah Fahad Al
Odah

002
065
205
213

217

220
228

229
232

Yes
Yes
No
Yes

No

No
Yes

No
No







Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes



Yes





Yes








Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 2 of 25

2

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)
Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Al Odah v. United States, 02-CV-828 (CKK)

Kurnaz v. Bush, 04-CV-1135 (ESH)
O.K. v. Bush, 04-CV-1136 (JDB)
El Banna v. Bush, 04-CV-1144 (RWR)
El Banna v. Bush, 04-CV-1144 (RWR)
El Banna v. Bush, 04-CV-1144 (RWR)
Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)
Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)
Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)



Fwad Mahmoud Al Rabiah
Fayiz Mohammed Ahmed Al
Kandari
Adil Zamil Abdull Mohssin Al
Zamil
Saad Madai Saad Ha Wash Al-
Azmi
Murat Kurnaz
Omar Khadr
Jamil El-Banna
Bisher Al-Rawi
Martin Mubanga
Belkacem Bensayah
Saber Lahmar
Mohammed Nechle

551
552

568

571

061
766
905
906
10007
10001
10002
10003

Yes
Yes

No

No

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes





Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes



Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 3 of 25



3

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)
Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)
Boumediene v. Bush, 05-CV-1166 (RJL)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)

Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)

Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)

Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)

Mustafa Ait Idir
Lakhdar Boumediene
Hadj Boudella
Ali Ahmed Mohammed Al Rezehi
Ali Husayn Al Tays
Ali Yahya Mahdi
Saeed Ahmed Mohammed Al
Sarim
Khaled Ahmed Qassim Muse'd
Riyad Atag Ali Abdoh Al Haj
Abdul Khaleq Ahmed Sahleh Al-
Baidhani
Jalal Salim Bin Amer
Suhail Abdoh Anam
Abdualaziz Abdoh Abdullah Ali
Al Swidhi
Emad Abdullah Hassan

10004
10005
10006
045
162
167
235

242
256
553

564
569
578

680

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
No
Yes

Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes



Yes

Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 4 of 25

4

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)

Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Anam v. Bush, 04-CV-1194 (HHK)
Al Qosi v. Bush, 04-CV-1937 (PLF)

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)

Fahmi Abdullah Ahmed Al
Tawlaqi
Bashir Nasir Ali Al Marwalah
Musa'ab Omar Al Mudwani
Ibrahim Ahmed Mahmoud Al
Qosi
Othman Abdulraheem Mohammad
Mahmoad Abdah
Farouk Ali Ahmed Saif
Abdulmalik Abdulwahhab Al-
Rahabi
Majid Mahmoud Ahmed
Sadeq Mohammed Said
Makhtar Yahia Naji Al-Wrafie
Adnan Farhan Abdul Latif
Adil Saeed El Haj Obaid

688

837
839
054

027
031
032
037

041
069
117
156
165

Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
No
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes



Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 5 of 25

5

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)

Abdah v. Bush, 04-CV-1254 (HHK)
Hamdan v. Bush, 04-CV-1519 (JR)
Paracha v. Bush, 04-CV-2022 (PLF)
Al Marri v. Bush, 04-CV-2035 (GK)
Zemiri v. Bush, 04-CV-2046 (CKK)
Deghayes v. Bush, 04-CV-2215 (RMC)
Deghayes v. Bush, 04-CV-2215 (RMC)
Deghayes v. Bush, 04-CV-2215 (RMC)
Abdullah v. Bush, 05-CV-0023 (RWR)

Salman Yahaldi Hsan Mohammed
Saud
Yasein Khasem Mohammad
Esmail
Jamal Mar'i
Mohamed Mohamed Hassan
Odaini
Aref Abd II Rheem
Salim Ahmed Hamdan
Saifullah Paracha
Jarallah Al Marri
Ahcene Zemiri
Shaker Abdurraheem Aamer
Jamel Abdullah Kiyemba
Omar Deghayes
Rami Bin Saad Al-Oteibi

508

522

577
681

Unidentified

149
1094
334
533
239
701
727
318

Yes

Yes

Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes

Yes

Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 6 of 25

6

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Abdullah v. Bush, 05-CV-0023 (RWR)
Al Mohammad v. Bush, 05-CV-247 (HHK)
El Mashad v. Bush, 05-CV-270 (JR)
El Mashad v. Bush, 05-CV-270 (JR)
El Mashad v. Bush, 05-CV-270 (JR)
Al Adahi v. Bush, 05-CV-280 (GK)
Al Adahi v. Bush, 05-CV-280 (GK)
Al Adahi v. Bush, 05-CV-280 (GK)

Al Adahi v. Bush, 05-CV-280 (GK)
Al Adahi v. Bush, 05-CV-280 (GK)
Al Joudi v. Bush, 05-CV-301 (GK)
Al Joudi v. Bush, 05-CV-301 (GK)

Hani Saleh Rashid Abdullah
Mahmood Salim Al-Mohammed
Sherif el-Mashad
Adel Fattouh Aly Ahmed Algazzar
Alladeen
Muhammad Al-Adahi
Muhammad Ali Abdullah Bawazir
Suleiman Awadh Bin Aqil Al-
Nahdi
Fahmi Salem Al-Assani
Zahir Omar Khamis Bin Hamdoon
Majid Abdulla Al Joudi
Yousif Mohammad Mubarak Al-
Shehri

841
537
190
369
716
033
261
511

554
576
025
114

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
No









Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes



Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 7 of 25



7

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Al Joudi v. Bush, 05-CV-301 (GK)
Al Joudi v. Bush, 05-CV-301 (GK)

Al Wazan v. Bush, 05-CV-329 (PLF)
Al Anazi v. Bush, 05-CV-345 (JDB)
Al Anazi v. Bush, 05-CV-345 (JDB)
Al Anazi v. Bush, 05-CV-345 (JDB)
Al Anazi v. Bush, 05-CV-345 (JDB)
Al Anazi v. Bush, 05-CV-345 (JDB)
Alhami v. Bush, 05-CV-359 (GK)

Alhami v. Bush, 05-CV-359 (GK)
Ameziane v. Bush, 05-CV-392 (ESH)
Batarfi v. Bush, 05-CV-409 (EGS)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)


Abdulla Mohammad Al Ghanmi
Abdul-Hakim Abdul-Rahman Al-
Moosa
Ahmed Abdullah Al-Wazan
Abdulaziz Sa'ad Oshan
Ibrahim Suleiman Al-Rubaish
Adel Egla Hussan Al-Nussairi
Naief Fahad Mutlaq Al-Otaibi
Abdulla Thani Faris Al-Anazi
Rafiq Bin Bashir Bin Jallul
Alhami
Mohammed Abdul Rahman
Jamel Ameziane
Aymen Saeed Batarfi
Adel Al Hakeemy
Hisham Sliti

266
565

197
112
192
308
436
514
892

894
310
627
168
174

Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes

Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 8 of 25



8

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)




Yousuf Al Karany
Abdul Aziz Al Mossary
Sami Muhyideen
Ibrahim Towkah
Ahmad Abu Abduttawaab
Muhammed Sidii
Abdul Al Hadi
Mustafa Ibrahim
Amir Yakub
Abdullah
Ibrahim Fauzee
Mahmoud Al Soury
Adel Turkestani
Mohamad Morotany

269
287
345
684
704
706
717
719
720
721
730

Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified

Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No








Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes



Yes



Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes







Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 9 of 25



9

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006

Sliti v. Bush, 05-CV-429 (RJL)
Kabir v. Bush, 05-CV-431 (RJL)

Kabir v. Bush, 05-CV-431 (RJL)
Kabir v. Bush, 05-CV-431 (RJL)
Kabir v. Bush, 05-CV-431 (RJL)
Kabir v. Bush, 05-CV-431 (RJL)
Qayed v. Bush, 05-CV-454 (RMU)
Al Shihry v. Bush, 05-CV-490 (PLF)

Aziz v. Bush, 05-CV-492 (JR)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)


Hassan Al Gassary
Ayman Mohammed Ahmed Al
Shurfa
Khalid Mahmoud Alasmar
Usama Hasan Abu Kabir
Ahmad Hassan Jamil Suleiman
Ibrahim Mahdi Ahmed Zaidan
Rashid Abdul Mosleh Qayed
Abdul-Salam Gaithan Mureef Al-
Shihry
Ahamed Abdul Aziz
Muhammed Fahad Al Qahtany
Abdul Rahman Shalby
Musa Al Madany
Abdullah Aali Al Otaibi
Saleh Abdulla Al-Oshan

Unidentified

331

589
651
662
761
344
132

757
013
042
058
243
248



Yes

No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes



Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 10 of 25



10

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-520 (RMU)
Tumani v. Bush, 05-CV-526 (RMU)
Tumani v. Bush, 05-CV-526 (RMU)
Al Oshan v. Bush, 05-CV-533 (RJL)

Mammar v. Bush, 05-CV-573 (RJL)
Al Sharekh v. Bush, 05-CV-583 (RJL)
Al Sharekh v. Bush, 05-CV-583 (RJL)
Magram v. Bush, 05-CV-584 (CKK)
Al Daini v. Bush, 05-CV-634 (RWR)
Errachidi v. Bush, 05-CV-640 (EGS)
Adem v. Bush, 05-CV-723 (RWR)
Aboassy v. Bush, 05-CV-748 (RMC)
Aboassy v. Bush, 05-CV-748 (RMC)
Aboassy v. Bush, 05-CV-748 (RMC)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)

Zaben Dhaher Al Shammari
Abd Al Nisr Khan Tumani
Muhammed Khan Tumani
Sulaiman Saad Mohaammed Al-
Oshan
Ameur Mammar
Abdulrazzaq Abdulla Al-Sharekh
Abdulhadi Abdulla Al-Sharekh
Murtadha Ali Magram
Omer Saeed Salem Al Daini
Ahmed Errachidi
Salim Muhood Adem
Sameer Najy Hasan Mukbel
Mohsen Abdrub Aboassy
Mohammed Saeed Bin Salman
Lahcen Ikasrien

647
307
312
121

939
067
231
187
549
590
710
043
091
251
072

Yes
No
Yes
Yes

Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes



Yes
Yes

Yes


No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No








Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 11 of 25

11

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006

Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Imran v. Bush, 05-CV-764 (CKK)
Al Habashi v. Bush, 05-CV-765 (EGS)
Al Hamamy v. Bush, 05-CV-766 (RJL)

Najeeb Al Husseini
Tareq
Said
Younis Shakur
Abdul Latif Mohammed Nasser
Moussa
Mohammed Mazoz
Ridouane Shakur
Mohammed Al Nadour
Mohammed Fahreo
Benjamin Mohammed Al Habashi
Abdul Hadi Ibn El Hathily Al
Hamamy
Sofian Ebrahim Hamad Hamoodah
Khiali-Gul

075
133
150
197
244
270
294
499

Unidentified
Unidentified

1458
717

No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No



Yes
Yes




Yes
Yes








Yes
Yes*

557
928

Hamoodah v. Bush, 05-CV-795 (RJL)
Khiali-Gul v. Bush, 05-CV-877 (JR)

* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.
Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.

Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 12 of 25



12

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Nasrat v. Bush, 05-CV-880 (ESH)
Muhibullah v. Bush, 05-CV-884 (RMC)
Mohammad v. Bush, 05-CV-885 (GK)
Wahab v. Bush, 05-CV-886 (EGS)
Chaman v. Bush, 05-CV-887 (RWR)
Gul v. Bush, 05-CV-888 (CKK)
Basardh v. Bush, 05-CV-889 (ESH)
Sohail v. Bush, 05-CV-993 (RMU)
Tohirjanovich v. Bush, 05-CV-994 (JDB)

Sarajuddin v. Bush, 05-CV-1000 (PLF)
Mohammad v. Bush, 05-CV-1002 (EGS)
Mangut v. Bush, 05-CV-1008 (JDB)
Hamad v. Bush, 05-CV-1009 (JDB)




Haji Nasrat
Muhibullah
Alif Mohammad
Abdul Wahab
Chaman
Nazul Gul
Yasin Muhammed Basardh
Mohammad Mustafa Sohail
Kasimbekov Komoliddin
Tohirjanovich
Abib Sarajuddin
Akhtar Mohammed
Habibullah Mangut
Adel Hassan Hamad

1009
974
972
961
1021
1037
252
1008
675

458
845
907
940

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
No
Yes
Yes

Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 13 of 25



13

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Khan v. Bush, 05-CV-1010 (RJL)
Al Hela v. Bush, 05-CV-1048 (RMU)

Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Mousouvi v. Bush, 05-CV-1124 (RMC)
Khalif v. Bush, 05-CV-1189 (JR)
Zalita v. Bush, 05-CV-1220 (RMU)
Ahmed v. Bush, 05-CV-1234 (EGS)
Aminullah v. Bush, 05-CV-1237 (ESH)




Mohabat Khan
Abdulsalam Ali Abdulrahman Al-
Hela
Wali Mohammed Morafa
Haji Rohullah Wakil
Sabar Lal
Izaatullah Nusrat
Haji Nusrat
Abdul Razak Iktiar Mohammed
Ali Shah Mousovi
Omar Mohammed Khalifh
Abu Abdul Rauf Zalita
Labed Ahmed
Aminullah

909
1463

560
798
801
977
1009
1043
1154
695
709
703
848

Yes
Yes

Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
No
Yes

Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 14 of 25



14

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Ghalib v. Bush, 05-CV-1238 (CKK)
Bukhari v. Bush, 05-CV-1241 (RMC)

Pirzai v. Bush, 05-CV-1242 (RCL)
Peerzai v. Bush, 05-CV-1243 (RCL)
Mohammadi v. Bush, 05-CV-1246 (RWR)
Al Ginco v. Bush, 05-CV-1310 (RJL)

Ullah v. Bush, 05-CV-1311 (RCL)
Mohammed v. Bush, 05-CV-1347 (GK)
Saib v. Bush, 05-CV-1353 (RMC)
Hatim v. Bush, 05-CV-1429 (RMU)
Hatim v. Bush, 05-CV-1429 (RMU)

Al Subaiy v. Bush, 05-CV-1453 (RMU)

Dhiab v. Bush, 05-CV-1457 (GK)

Haji Ghalib
Abdul Hakim Abdul Karim Amin
Bukhari
Ahsanullah Pirzai
Ihsan Ullah Peerzai
Abdul Majid Mohammadi
Abdulrahim Abdul Razak Al
Ginco
Ehsan Ullah
Farhi Saeed bin Mohammed
Motai Saib
Saeed Mohammed Saleh Hatim
Mohammed Nasser Yahia
Abdullah Khussrof
Nasser Mazyad Abdullah Al-
Subaiy
Jihad Dhiab

987
493

562
562
555
489

562
311
288
255
509

497

722

Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes

Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes

No
No
Yes
Yes

No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes

No





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 15 of 25

15

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Sadkhan v. Bush, 05-CV-1487 (RMC)
Faizullah v. Bush, 05-CV-1489 (RMU)
Faraj v. Bush, 05-CV-1490 (PLF)
Khan v. Bush, 05-CV-1491 (JR)
Ahmad v. Bush, 05-CV-1492 (RCL)
Al Wirghi v. Bush, 05-CV-1497 (RCL)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)
Kiyemba v. Bush, 05-CV-1509 (RMU)

Jawad Jabber Sadkhan
Faizullah
Abdul Hadi Omer Hamoud Faraj
Sawat Khan
Abdul Ahmad
Adil Bin Muhammad Al Wirghi
Abdusabur Doe
Abdunasir Doe
Khalid Doe
Saabir Doe
Jalaal Doe
Abdusamad Doe
Hudhaifa Doe
Hammad Doe
Saddiq Doe

433
919
329
933
956
502
275
278
280
282
285
295
320
328
491

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes








Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 16 of 25

16

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Idris v. Bush, 05-CV-1555 (JR)
Attash v. Bush, 05-CV-1592 (RCL)
Mamet v. Bush, 05-CV-1602 (ESH)
Rabbani v. Bush, 05-CV-1607 (RMU)
Rabbani v. Bush, 05-CV-1607 (RMU)
Zahir v. Bush, 05-CV-1623 (RWR)
Ghanem v. Bush, 05-CV-1638 (CKK)
Al Badah v. Bush, 05-CV-1641 (CKK)
Al Badah v. Bush, 05-CV-1641 (CKK)
Al Badah v. Bush, 05-CV-1641 (CKK)
Almerfedi v. Bush, 05-CV-1645 (PLF)

Zaid v. Bush, 05-CV-1646 (JDB)
Al Bahooth v. Bush, 05-CV-1666 (ESH)

Ali Ahmed v. Bush, 05-CV-1678 (GK)

Ibrahim Osman Ibrahim Idris
Hassan Bin Attash
Edham Mamet
Abdul Raheem Ghulam Rabbani
Ahmmed Ghulam Rabbani
Abdul Zahir
Mohammed Rajeb Abu Ghanem
Abdulaziz Abdulrahman Al-Badah
Ibrahim Mohammed Al-Naser
Abdulaziz Mohammed Al-Naser
Hussain Salem Mohammed
Almerfedi
Waleed Saeed Bn Saeed Zaid
Ziyad bin Salih bin Muhammad
Al-Bahooth
Alla Ali Bin Ali Ahmed

036
1456
102
1460
1461
753
044
264
271
273
1015

550
272

692

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes

Yes





Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes

Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 17 of 25

17

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Kabir (Sadar Doe) v. Bush, 05-CV-1704 (JR) Arkeen Doe
Kabir (Sadar Doe) v. Bush, 05-CV-1704 (JR)
Sadar Doe
Al Rubaish v. Bush, 05-CV-1714 (RWR)
Yousif Abdullah Al-Rubaish
Sameur v. Bush, 05-CV-1806 (CKK)
Abdannour Sameur
Al Qahtani v. Bush, 05-CV-1971 (RMC)
Mohammed al-Qahtani
Alkhemisi v. Bush, 05-CV-1983 (RMU)
Ismail Alkhemisi
Alkhemisi v. Bush, 05-CV-1983 (RMU)
Hasan Balgaid
Gamil v. Bush, 05-CV-2010 (JR)
Ravil Mingaza Gamil
Al-Shabany v. Bush, 05-CV-2029 (JDB)
Bender Ayed Hamoud Hezam Al-
Oteibi Al-Shabany
Khaled Abd Elgabar Mohammed
Othman
Abdu Al-Qader Hussain Al-
Mudafari

Al Mudafari v. Bush, 05-CV-2185 (JR)

Othman v. Bush, 05-CV-2088 (RWR)

103
277
109
659
063
708

Unidentified

702
332

163

040

Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes

Yes

Yes









Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes


No
Yes

Yes

Yes

Al Mithali v. Bush, 05-CV-2186 (ESH)
Alhag v. Bush, 05-CV-2199 (HHK)

Nakheelan v. Bush, 05-CV-2201 (ESH)
Al Subaie v. Bush, 05-CV-2216 (RCL)

Al Subaie v. Bush, 05-CV-2216 (RCL)
Al Subaie v. Bush, 05-CV-2216 (RCL)

Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)
Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)
Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)

Hayal Aziz Ahmed Al-Mithali
Abd Al Hakim Ghalib Ahmad
Alhag
Naif Abdulla Al Nakheelan
Alghamdi Abdulrahman Othman
A
Bijad Defalla Oteibi
Mohammed Bin Jaied Bin Aladi
Al Mohammed Al Subaie
Fahd Abdullah Ahmed Ghazy
Moath Hamza Ahmed Al Alwi
Abdallah Yahya Youssef
Allsshaballi
Mohammed Ali Hussain Khanina
Zaher Omer Bin Hamdoon

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
No

No


No


No
No
No

840
686

258
095

122
319

026
028
240

Yes
Yes

Yes
No

Yes
No

Yes
Yes
Yes

254
576

Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 18 of 25



18

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)
Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)


* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.

Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.


No
Yes*

Yes
Yes





Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 19 of 25



19

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006

Ghazy v. Bush, 05-CV-2223 (RJL)
Al Shimrani v. Bush, 05-CV-2249 (RMC)

Al Sharbi v. Bush, 05-CV-2348 (EGS)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Zadran v. Bush, 05-CV-2367 (RWR)
Alsaaei v. Bush, 05-CV-2369 (RWR)
Razakah v. Bush, 05-CV-2370 (EGS)

Fadi Ahmad Alimaqaleh
Mohammed Abudul Rahman Al-
Shimrani
Ghassan Abdullah Al Sharbi
Ghulam Roohani
Abdul Haq
Mohammad Wabi Umari
Abdullah Wazir Zadran
Dr. Hiyatullah
Chaman Gul Khialigol
Tooran Mohammad Amannullah
Abdullah Mujahid Haq
Mohammad Zahir
Mohammad Rahim
Abdullah Ali Saleh Gerab Alsaaei
Ahmad Doe

Unidentified

195

682
003
004
832
976
1001
1021
1074
1100
1103
1104
340
201



Yes

Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes









Yes

Yes
Yes






Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 20 of 25



20

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Razakah v. Bush, 05-CV-2370 (EGS)
Al Darby v. Bush, 05-CV-2371 (RCL)
Al-Ghizzawi v. Bush, 05-CV-2378 (JDB)

Awad v. Bush, 05-CV-2379 (JR)
Al Baidany v. Bush, 05-CV-2380 (CKK)
Al Rammi v. Bush, 05-CV-2381 (JDB)
Said v. Bush, 05-CV-2384 (RWR)
Said v. Bush, 05-CV-2384 (RWR)
Said v. Bush, 05-CV-2384 (RWR)
Said v. Bush, 05-CV-2384 (RWR)
Said v. Bush, 05-CV-2384 (RWR)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)

Abdur Razakah
Ahmad Mohammed Al Darbi
Abdul Hamid Abdul Salam Al-
Ghizzawi
Adham Mohammed Ali Awad
Zakaria Al-Baidany
Ismail Ali Al Rammi
Salim Said
Bandar Al Jaabir
Saad Al Qahtaani
Anwar Handan Al Shimmiri
Mohammed Zahrani
Abul Aziz Al Matrafi
Mohamed Rajab
Saif
Majed Baryan

209
768
654

088
1017

Unidentified

126
182
200
226
713
005
044
046
051

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes



Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes
Yes
No

Yes
No


Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes




Yes*
No
No

* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.
Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.






Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 21 of 25



21

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)

Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)

Saud Al Jouhany
Waqas Mohammed Ali Awad
Abd Al Rahman Abdullah Al
Halmandy
Hisham
Moussa
Sultan Al Shareef
Abu Rawdah
Inshanullah
Adel
Sabry Mohammed
Dr. Ayman
Fawaz
Abdu Tawab
Muhammad Nur Uthman
Muhammad

062
088
118

174
196
215
326
367
502
570
627
678
704
707

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
No

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
No
Yes*
No

Yes*
No

No

No


Yes*



Yes*



* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.
Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.






Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 22 of 25



22

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)

Abdul Al Hamman
Abdulla
Muhammed Saad Iqbal Madni
Said Madany
Shamsullah
Rafiove bin Bashir
Saki Bacha
Zakaria
Mohammed Kameen
Abdo Ali Al Haj
Abdulrahman
Ibrahim Nayif Abdallah Ibrahim
Abu Baker Shammrany
Saleh Libi
Salah Deen Ibn Shaikh
Salih

717
721
743
743
783
892
900
1017
1045
1457
1463

Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified

Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Yes







Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
Yes*




No
Yes*


No



Yes*







* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.
Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.




Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 23 of 25



23

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006

Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)

Riad Nargeri
Ridah
Abdullah
Sanjawez Raweel Kameel Weej
Abdal Rauf Zalitini
Ahamed
Abdullah ali Saleh
Othman Ali Muhammed Omar
Amar Biloushi
Mohammed Chinguity
Abdulrahman
Ali Kadami
Khalid Deshire
Abou Yassir Jezairi
Abdaul Razak Ali-Haj
Adnan

Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified











































Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 24 of 25

24

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006

Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Al Halmandy v. Bush, 05-CV-2385 (RMU)
Thabid v. Bush, 05-CV-2398 (ESH)
Thabid v. Bush, 05-CV-2398 (ESH)

Abdullah Jaffa
Abu Hadifa
Mohammed Abdullah
Mohamed Fahad Saad Al Zu'bi
Abdul Aziz
Abdul Latif
Abdulla Haji
Bital Adel Halami
Houmad Warzly
Saleh
Khalid Mohammed
Mahdi Salih
Masoud
Ali
Thabid

Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified
Unidentified















250
289

Yes
No














No










Case 1:05-cv-01429-UNA Document 56-2 Filed 08/15/2006 Page 25 of 25

25

Case

Petitioner’s Name

Petitioner’s

ISN

Materials

Seized

Rimi v. Bush, 05-CV-2427 (RJL)
Al Salami v. Bush, 05-CV-2452 (PLF)
Al Salami v. Bush, 05-CV-2452 (PLF)
Al Shareef v. Bush, 05-CV-2458 (RWR)

Al Shareef v. Bush, 05-CV-2458 (RWR)

Mohammad Rimi
Abdullah Al Sali Al Asoriya
Saleh Ali Abdullah Al Salami
Fahd Umar Abdulmajid Al
Shareef
Hani Saeed Mohammed Banan Al-
Kalf Al-Gamdi
Anwar Khan
Mubark Hussein
Ahmed Al-Delebany
Ghanim-Abdulrahman al-Harbi
Ravil Mingazov
Zainulabidin Merozhev
Abdulli Feghoul
Abbas Abid Rumi

Possible

Attorney-Client
Communications
Before June 18,

2006
No
Yes




Yes

194
340
693
215

438

Yes
Yes
No
No

Yes

Khan v. Bush, 05-CV-2466 (RCL)
Hussein v. Bush, 05-CV-2467 (PLF)
Al Delebany v. Bush, 05-CV-2477 (RMU)
Al Harbi v. Bush, 05-CV-2479 (HHK)
Al Harbi v. Bush, 05-CV-2479 (HHK)
Al Harbi v. Bush, 05-CV-2479 (HHK)
Feghoul v. Bush, 06-CV-618 (RWR)
Rumi v. Bush, 06-CV-619 (RJL)

* Respondents have identified petitioner as having a previously-filed habeas corpus petition in another case listed on this chart.
Communication with counsel, if any, would have occurred only in connection with the previously-filed case.

No
No
Yes*
No
No
No
No
No

948
151
553
516
702
1095
292
758

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes